ATL to win-170
TLDR: The Braves won, but mostly not for our reasons. Luzardo gave 5 strong innings and Sale left trailing 3-2. Riley's 3-run homer in the 8th, off a short-handed Phillies bullpen, won it. That fits only our point about the bullpens.
Point
- Sale vs. Philly
Chris Sale held these Phillies to a 2.08 ERA over 4 starts this year, so seeing him often has not helped them.
Hurt us3 runs in 6.1 innings, left with Atlanta trailing 3-2 - Rest and travel
Atlanta clinched on September 20 and set up its staff, while Philadelphia clinched Sunday, flew Monday and plays Tuesday afternoon.
Helped usRested Atlanta relievers closed it; short Philly pen allowed 4 runs - No Wheeler
Zack Wheeler threw 97 pitches in Sunday's clincher, so Philadelphia's ace can't start Game 1 and it opens with a limited Luzardo.
Helped usLuzardo went 5 strong, but the pen still covered 4 innings - Truist Park
Atlanta went 52-29 at home and won the season series 9-4, and all 3 games of this series are in Atlanta.
Helped usAtlanta won at home on Riley's 8th-inning homer
Counterpoint
- October history
Philadelphia knocked out Braves teams with better records in both 2022 and 2023, so this core has won playoff games in this building.
Didn't matterPhillies led in the 8th but couldn't finish it - Harper vs. Iglesias
Bryce Harper is 6-for-12 with 4 home runs against closer Raisel Iglesias, which makes any close 9th inning a real risk.
Didn't matterPhillies went scoreless in the 9th; the matchup never mattered
Neutral
- Weather
Sunny, low 80s and light, variable wind for an afternoon first pitch, so the conditions don't favor the pitchers or the hitters.
Didn't matterRecap never mentions conditions affecting play - Robert Suarez
Setup man Robert Suarez made the roster after missing 3 months with an elbow injury, so he's a big arm but an unknown one.
Didn't matterRecap does not mention Suarez
