BOS to win+122
TLDR: The bet lost, and mostly for the reasons we listed against it: Fried held Boston to 3 hits over 6 innings. Gray kept it close through 5, but the rested bullpen we counted on gave up 6 runs in the 6th, starting with Crochet.
Point
- Gray vs. New York
Gray posted a 1.98 ERA in 2 starts against the Yankees this year, and Boston won both, including one at Yankee Stadium.
Helped usAllowed 2 runs through 5 innings and kept it close. - Boston's bullpen
Chapman, Whitlock and Crochet all sat out Game 1, and none of the 5 relievers used got more than 4 outs, so the full late-game plan is available.
Hurt usCrochet opened the 6th, retired 1 of 4, and the inning became 6 runs. - Lefty on lefty
Boston carries 5 left-handed relievers (Chapman, Crochet, Miller, Gamboa, Bennett) against a Yankees order whose lefties went 8-for-18 in Game 1.
Hurt usLefties Bellinger and García Jr. homered; Bellinger drove in 4. - Righty bats vs. Fried
8 of Boston's 9 starters hit from the right side or switch-hit, and the club has a .768 OPS against left-handed pitching this season.
Hurt usBoston managed 4 hits all game, 3 off Fried.
Counterpoint
- Roman Anthony
An MRI found new strains in his right hand, and he is off the roster for the rest of the series, taking Boston's leadoff man out.
Hurt usMissed the game, and a short-handed lineup got 4 hits. - Fried vs. Boston
Fried has a 1.93 career ERA in 7 starts against Boston and has allowed them 1 run over 11⅔ innings this year.
Hurt us6 innings, 1 earned run, 6 strikeouts.
Neutral
- Rest
A nor'easter wiped out the Yankees' final weekend, and both clubs saved their closers in Game 1, so neither side has a rest edge.
Didn't matterBoth bullpens were available, and rest didn't decide anything. - Weather
Mostly cloudy and in the upper 60s at first pitch, with a 5-7 mph breeze, so the air gives no help to either lineup.
Didn't matterMild conditions, and neither lineup got help from the air.
