Big Cat's Iowa pick vs. Michigan is an insult, says Portnoy

By JR·2 min read
Big Cat's Iowa pick vs. Michigan is an insult, says Portnoy

TLDR: Big Cat put Iowa +5.5 against Michigan in the Barstool College Football Show's Week 4 Dark Horse Parlay, and Dave Portnoy called it an insult pick on a show where he also cried collusion over the Top 10.

  1. Thu Sep 246:07 PM CT

    Week 4 Drops With A Top 10

    The Week 4 episode of the Barstool College Football Show went live Thursday night, and the crew pushed it everywhere at once. Big Cat, Kayce Smith, Brandon Walker, Mike Katic and Dave all had their parts to play. The picks were the main event, but before anyone locked a leg the fight started over the weekly consensus Top 10.

    Big Cat
    Big Cat
    @BarstoolBigCat

    Tune in to @BarstoolCFB Week 4. Live now t.co/zLotfNDRc2

    The consensus list is the show's weekly argument starter, and this week the bottom of it was the problem. Mississippi State got the 9 spot. Michigan, Dave's team, came in 1 slot behind at 10.

    Barstool Sports
    @barstoolsportstv

    “Texas, Indiana, Georgia, Ole Miss, Miami, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Alabama, Mississippi State, and Michigan.”

    Dave did not take it quietly. With the graphic showing Miss St 9 and Michigan 10, he floated the theory that the rest of the panel had gotten together to bury the Wolverines. It is a bit, obviously. It is also the most Dave way possible to react to your team sitting at 10 instead of 9.

    Viva La Stool
    Viva La Stool
    @VivaLaStool

    Dave thinks we may have had some collusion on this week’s Top 10 rankings. Do you agree with this list? @Vegas

    So Michigan was already in a bad spot on the show before anyone got to the parlay. Then the parlay made it worse.

  2. Fri Sep 253:02 PM CT

    The Insult Pick

    The DraftKings Dark Horse Parlay is 4 underdogs, 1 from each guy. Dave took Western Michigan +7, Brandon took Iowa State +8.5, Katic took Michigan State +5.5, and Big Cat took Iowa +5.5 against Michigan. Out of every underdog on the board, Big Cat picked the one playing Dave's school, on Dave's show, the same week Dave was already complaining about Michigan's ranking. Portnoy's reaction, as quoted in the clip's caption: insult pick.

    Barstool Gambling
    Barstool Gambling
    @stoolgambling

    .@BarstoolBigCat picking Iowa to cover vs Michigan in the Dark Horse parlay is diabolical “Insult pick” - @stoolpresidente @DKSports #DKpartner

    The number is real. Michigan is laying 5.5 at home in a game with a total of just 38.5, and a low total like that makes a 6-point spread feel huge. Dave, meanwhile, spent the week on his own dog. On Wednesday's Pick Em he was already on Western Michigan and happy to call it Dave ball.

    Barstool Gambling
    @BarstoolGambling

    “It's a little bit of the Dave ball here. Western plus six and a half at home against Boise. I think they beat Boise.” – Dave Portnoy

    He stuck with it. Dave's Mortals pick on Friday was Western Michigan again, this time at +6.5, 1 point off his parlay number. Big Cat's Mortals pick was the OSU/UTEP over, which lasted about 2 hours and 40 minutes.

    Barstool Pick Em
    Barstool Pick Em
    @Barstoolpickem

    WEEK 4 MORTALS @stoolpresidente WMU +6.5 @BarstoolBigCat OSU/UTEP o55.5 @Return_Of_RB New Mexico -11.5 @hen_ease Texas -4.5 @jmccarthy55 UNLV -13.5 @KevinZuppe UGA -14 @EBoKnowss Wisco +10

  3. Fri Sep 255:40 PM CT

    Big Cat Flips, Then Piles On

    Friday evening Big Cat used his 1 legal flip, and made sure to cite the Pick Em bylaws when he did it. He moved off the UTEP over and onto LSU -8.5. He also warned that more picks were coming.

    Big Cat
    Big Cat
    @BarstoolBigCat

    I will have some adds to my card but I’ve made one flip (as legally allowed per pick em bylaws) Flipping to LSU -8.5 @Barstoolpickem @jmccarthy55

    They came at 9:30 PM CT. His adds were Auburn -9.5, Iowa State +7.5, Georgia Southern +17.5, the Louisville over 57.5, Utah State -3 and Oregon -3. That's 6 more legs, and the Iowa State pick means he's now on the same Cyclones side Dave liked on Pick Em.

    Barstool Pick Em
    Barstool Pick Em
    @Barstoolpickem

    Adds for @BarstoolBigCat Auburn-9.5 Iowa State +7.5 Georgia Southern +17.5 Louisville Over 57.5 Utah State -3 Oregon -3

    Big Cat's card is huge now, but the pick that matters in this fight is still Iowa +5.5. Kickoff in Ann Arbor is 3:30 PM ET Saturday on CBS, the same window as Ole Miss at Florida, where Dave called himself a lunatic for taking Ole Miss and then took them anyway. If Iowa keeps it within 5, Big Cat gets to hold the insult pick over Dave for a while. If Michigan wins big, Dave gets to say he told everyone, and he'll still say the Top 10 was rigged.

Free Picks