Big Cat, PFT sweat Week 3, then ask if Drake Maye is broken

TLDR: Big Cat, PFT and the Barstool Chicago crew sweated the NFL Week 3 slate live from the Gambling Cave, then Monday's Pardon My Take picked apart Drake Maye's 35-6 faceplant in Jacksonville.
- Sun Sep 2711:06 AM CT
The Cave Opens For Business
Sunday started the way every Cave Sunday does, with Big Cat promising that this week would finally be the week. Last Thursday on Sports Advisors he told the whole table he was put on this earth to be wrong about every gambling pick, and on Sunday he was back to asking the timeline to trust him.
By the 1pm kickoffs the stream was up. Big Cat, PFT and the Chicago crew were on the leather couches with the DraftKings ticker running, a wall of TVs and a board full of Cave Bets.
Big Cat@BarstoolBigCatLive from the Gambling Cave for NFL Week 3 Live Now—> t.co/P9WbqFmOP2
On paper it was a nice setup, with Patriots-Jaguars, Bengals-Steelers and Panthers-Browns all in the early window. It did not stay nice for long.
- Sun Sep 2712:33 PM CT
Maye Coughs It Up, Pittsburgh Wakes Up
The first gasp of the day belonged to Drake Maye. The camera stayed on the room, not the TV, and that was plenty: a couch full of open mouths that slowly turned into grimaces. According to NESN, Maye's first turnover came at the end of the 1st quarter, when he fumbled while trying to throw.
Meanwhile Big Cat had a sweat of his own. On Thursday's Sports Advisors he said Pittsburgh's offense couldn't block and called the Bengals-Steelers under the easiest money of his life.
Barstool Gambling@BarstoolGambling“This is gonna be the easiest game, easiest money I've ever made. It's the under 42 and a half.” – Big Cat
Naturally, the Steelers then scored more than 7 points in a 1st quarter for the first time in a very long time. A late 1st-quarter touchdown put Pittsburgh at 13 before the extra point, and the easiest money of his life was already in trouble.
- Sun Sep 271:51 PM CT
Hank's Parents And Max's iPad
By halftime the ticker showed Jacksonville up 14-3 on New England, which is playing in the international series this year. That set up the best exchange of the afternoon. Nicky Smokes asked Hank if he'd ever been to an international game, and Hank answered like a 12-year-old.
Barstool Gambling@stoolgambling“Hank have you been to an international game before?” - @nickysmokess “No my parents won’t let me” - @hen_ease
The same ticker had Bengals-Steelers tied 17-17 at the half. That's 34 points against Big Cat's 42.5 under with 2 quarters left. Max, meanwhile, had checked out of football completely. The Phillies had a must-win game, so the man sat in a room built for NFL Sunday and watched baseball on an iPad in his lap.
Even for the Cave, that's commitment. Nobody seemed surprised.
- Sun Sep 273:16 PM CT
Witching Hour Chaos
The late window is where the room lost control. In one stretch the Browns scored, the Bengals fumbled and the Commanders returned a pick for 6, all close enough together that the Cave just erupted at once. Someone in a Florida hoodie jumped up behind the couch.
Viva La Stool@VivaLaStoolIT’S CHAOS IN THE CAVE A BROWNS TOUCHDOWN A BENGALS FUMBLE AND A COMMANDERS PICK SIX
Then came the cruelest play of the day. The tweet has Chris Godwin taking a 3rd-and-29 ball 80 yards to the house before a holding flag wiped it out. The clip catches the whole emotional arc, from the leap to the hands on the head to the room going dead quiet.
"This slate is cursed" pretty much sums up the Sunday.
- Sun Sep 276:51 PM CT
Gremlin Hours
The stream ended, but the gambling didn't. PFT went into the night game with a bet only a degenerate could love, over 3.5 field goals. That's rooting for stalled drives and kickers, and he fully admitted it.
Big Cat, meanwhile, was taping Boomers when another pick six hit, and by his own account it wrecked the room. He didn't say which game.
That left Monday's Pardon My Take with plenty to cover and one obvious lead story.
- Mon Sep 286:41 AM CT
Is Drake Maye A Big Stupid Pick Guy
The final in Jacksonville was 35-6, Jaguars. Maye threw 2 interceptions and lost a fumble, including a Travis Hunter pick in the end zone just before halftime, and he was on the bench for Tommy DeVito by the 4th quarter. NESN counts 7 turnovers through 3 games, the most in the league. Monday's PMT framed it about as bluntly as possible.
The show went beyond Sunday, too. The stat cited in the segment goes back further: 9 fumbles and 10 interceptions over his last 7 games. That's not one bad afternoon, and Big Cat's episode rundown just called it "Drake Maye is Broken."
Things also got heated inside the studio. Somebody pointed at Max, and Max took it about as well as you'd expect.
The clip doesn't show what the pointing was about. It doesn't really matter.
- Mon Sep 289:07 AM CT
Dap Ups, Mariota And 2 Pounds
The episode kept producing clips through Monday. Big Cat used one to argue for Hank's dap-up résumé, a long record of famous people who apparently knew his name.
Hank also had the sharpest football question of the episode. Jayden Daniels dislocated his left elbow in Week 2, so Marcus Mariota started Sunday against the defending champion Seahawks, and Hank wanted to know whether the Commanders looked more fired up for the backup.
To finish things off, the crew got to the NBA preseason and the news that Chet Holmgren "bulked up" this offseason. He went from 213 pounds to 215, which is less of a bulk than one Sunday in the Cave with a Raising Cane's sponsorship.
Barstool Sports@barstoolsportsChet Holmgren bulked up in the offseason… He went from 213 pounds to 215 pounds
Next up is Week 4. Maye has to show the Patriots are more than a turnover machine, Washington has to keep going with Mariota, and Big Cat will be back on the couch telling everyone this is the week he finally wins. We'll see.
More Stories
Fiona the hippo dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing hat
Jon Gruden hangs up on Sam Darnold caller in Week 11 show
Steven Cheah watches Marvel movies for the first time
Barstool Greg misses flight, Burns takes off without him
Ohio's Tate owes 31 cans of corn after Ohio State loss
Connor Griffin Penn State Senior Day loss to Rutgers 25-24




