Dave Portnoy reviews Hideaway Pizza in Stillwater

TLDR: Dave Portnoy took the Barstool Pizza Review to Hideaway Pizza in Stillwater and scored it a 7.1, then rated Eskimo Joe's cheese fries before Barstool's live show at Oklahoma State.
Barstool's college football road trip landed in Stillwater on Saturday, and Dave Portnoy did what he does in every college town: he found the local pizza and the local legend.

Barstool Pizza Review - Hideaway Pizza (Stillwater, OK) Bonus Eskimo Joe's Cheese Fry Review t.co/qFmhWicJ6v
Hideaway is about as Stillwater as pizza gets. The original shop near the Oklahoma State campus has been around since the 1950s and grew into a chain across the state, so this wasn't a random strip-mall slice. According to Pistols Firing, Portnoy gave it a 7.1 and called it a better bite than he expected. That ties Hideaway for 614th out of the 1,144 places he has reviewed. Right in the middle of the pack. Respectable. No Oklahoma State fan is putting it on a banner, but nobody is starting a war over it either.
The bonus review is the one the Cowboys crowd actually cared about. Eskimo Joe's is the Stillwater bar, and per Pistols Firing, Portnoy went with the sweet pepper bacon cheese fries with ranch and gave them a 7.4. He also said they would probably taste better with a few drinks in you. That's not really an insult for a college bar's cheese fries. That's the point of college bar cheese fries.
Big Cat seemed to like it even more than Dave did. About an hour after the review went up, he gave Joe's his own one-line review.
The food was the side quest. The real reason the crew was in town was the Barstool College Football Show, which set up at Boone Pickens Stadium ahead of Oklahoma State hosting No. 10 Texas Tech. Big Cat sold it as a good old fashioned Big 12 shootout and told anyone going to the game to stop by the show first. Portnoy posted a look at the set before the 5:30 broadcast.
So the final Stillwater scorecard: a 7.1 for Hideaway, a 7.4 for Eskimo Joe's, and the fries beat the pizza. Every college town the show visits gets its own pizza review, and the comments section always argues over the score. Expect Cowboys fans to say Hideaway got shortchanged and Joe's got about what it deserved, while the rest of the night belongs to OSU and Texas Tech.
More Stories
Steven Cheah Either OR TD Parlay Steelers vs. Bengals over
Stu Feiner celebrates Vikings 30-10 win over Packers
Barstool College Football Show at Oklahoma State packs lot
Stu Feiner $100,000 Arizona +1.5 bet wins vs. Utah
Riggs, Bobby Ray, Fat Perez win 2026 Internet Invitational
Dave Portnoy gloats as Wake Forest routs SMU 49-7

