Big Cat's Summer of Burgers becomes a smash burger holy war

By JR·2 min read
Big Cat's Summer of Burgers becomes a smash burger holy war

TLDR: Big Cat declared it the Summer of Burgers, then declared smash burgers fake, and now Gaz is riding shotgun while JeffDLowe pokes at the obvious contradiction.

Every summer Big Cat picks a hill. This year the hill is 100 burgers — originally 200 until his wife shot him a look, and now somehow back to 200 because he can't help himself. It started as a wholesome grilling bit. It has since escalated into a referendum on what even counts as a burger in the year 2026.

Big Cat
Big Cat
@BarstoolBigCat

Btw this is grilling burgers. Maybe the occasional restaurant. I’m not talking fast food. I want to grill and eat 100 burgers (and tbh the original number was 200 but my wife gave me a look that told me I needed to do 100 but I’m actually gonna go for 200)

The pace has been honestly impressive. By Memorial Day Monday he was already 6 deep, freely admitting he needs to bank numbers before KB returns from Rediscovering America and inevitably tries to torch the leaderboard. The man is treating ground beef like a fantasy draft.

Big Cat
Big Cat
@BarstoolBigCat

I assume I’m free to count all of MDW for Burgers right? If so today was my 6th of the summer. 1 Saturday, 2 Sunday, 2 Monday, 1 Today.

Then PMT dropped and the bit graduated into a doctrine. Burgers are a man's food. Stop apologizing for them. And — the line that sent the timeline sideways — smash burgers are fake. Not bad. Fake. As in not real burgers. A genre disqualification.

Barstool Sports
Barstool Sports
@barstoolsports

“Smash burgers are fake. I don’t think those are real burgers” -@BarstoolBigCat

You can imagine how this went over with the internet, because the internet ran on smash burgers for about 4 years straight. Predictably the steak Twitter / grill hardo crowd descended, which Big Cat saw coming and preemptively quarantined inside what he keeps calling the Trust Tree. Doesn't matter. The takes are flying.

Gaz
Gaz
@stoolsalesguy

I’m 100% behind Big Cat on this take “Smash burgers are fake.” I’ll take it a step further and say I have no respect for anyone who chooses a smash over a regular burger.

Gaz going scorched earth — no respect for anyone choosing a smash over a regular burger — was the ride-or-die moment Big Cat needed. He quote-tweeted a thank you and dismissed the dissenters as not serious people. Which is when JeffDLowe stepped on the rake and pointed out the elephant in the kitchen.

Jeff D. Lowe
Jeff D. Lowe
@JeffDLowe

@stoolsalesguy Yeah but I know you like Hamburger America, right?

Hamburger America, for the uninitiated, is the George Motz smash burger temple in the West Village. It is arguably THE smash burger restaurant in America. Catching Gaz between his new anti-smash decree and his on-record love of the smash burger cathedral is the kind of gotcha that should end a movement. Gaz's escape hatch — he'll eat one if it's in front of him, but as a man he's not going out of his way — is the most Barstool sales guy answer possible. The Summer of Burgers is officially a war, and the front line is whatever you call the thing on the griddle at Hamburger America.

Free Picks