Malik Hooker, DeMarvion Overshown hurt in Cowboys' Giants loss

By JR·2 min read
Malik Hooker, DeMarvion Overshown hurt in Cowboys' Giants loss

TLDR: Dallas' 28-20 season-opening loss to the Giants got worse when Malik Hooker fractured his forearm and DeMarvion Overshown re-aggravated fears with a hamstring injury.

The Cowboys didn't just lose their opener to the Giants 28-20 — they lost two starters doing it. Malik Hooker went down late in the third quarter, and by the fourth, DeMarvion Overshown was in the medical tent too. Both would leave MetLife Stadium without answers, and Dallas would spend the next two days getting the bad news confirmed.

Hooker walked off pointing to his chest, which was the first sign it wasn't a stinger. Calvin Watkins and Clarence Hill Jr., both on the Cowboys beat, flagged him as hurt in real time, and within the hour Overshown was grabbing at his hamstring on the sideline after trying to run it off. He went to the blue tent, didn't come back, and was officially questionable with a hamstring issue before the game even ended.

That's the same knee-adjacent nightmare fans have lived through with Overshown before. He tore his ACL, MCL and PCL in his right knee against the Bengals in December 2024, a 343-day recovery that didn't get him back on the field until this past November. A hamstring strain isn't in the same universe of severity, but for a guy who just clawed his way back to full health, any tightness on the field is going to set off alarms in Dallas.

Hooker's injury turned out to be the more serious one. Ian Rapoport reported Sunday afternoon that the 29-year-old safety fractured a bone in his forearm and was consulting a hand specialist to nail down a recovery timeline — with some fractures healing in as little as two weeks and others sidelining a player for six.

Ian Rapoport
Ian Rapoport
@RapSheet

#Cowboys S Malik Hooker fractured a bone in his forearm and he’s consulting with a hand specialist to learn his recovery time, sources say. While some breaks can mean a player is out six weeks, the hope is based on the specific bone and break, it’s quicker than that.

Ian Rapoport: #Cowboys S Malik Hooker fractured a bone in his forearm and he’s consulting with a hand specialist to learn his recovery

Brian Schottenheimer cleared up the picture Monday: both Hooker and Overshown are expected to miss 1-2 weeks, not six, and Hooker is scheduled for surgery. It's a real bit of relief for a Cowboys secondary that just watched its highest-paid safety go down — Hooker signed a 3-year, $24 million extension in 2023 before reworking it to a 1-year, $5 million deal this past March, and he's been part of Dallas' defensive backbone ever since. Overshown's hamstring, for what it's worth, came on Cam Skattebo's 1-yard run with 11:40 left in the fourth.

With Overshown out even a couple weeks, Dee Winters, Jaishawn Barham and Shemar James are the names Schottenheimer floated at middle linebacker. None of them are DeMarvion Overshown on his best day, and Dallas already knows what an Overshown-less defense looks like from all of 2025. Losing him and Hooker in the same half of the same game, in Week 1, is not how this team wanted to open a season it's desperate to turn around after getting outmuscled at MetLife.

Free Picks