Dave Portnoy's NFL top 10: Bills 1st, Chiefs 3rd

By JR·2 min read
Dave Portnoy's NFL top 10: Bills 1st, Chiefs 3rd

TLDR: With his own teams finished, Dave Portnoy ranked the NFL's top 10 on Wake Up Barstool, putting the Bills 1st and the Chiefs 3rd and calling Drake Maye the MVP by his absence.

Dave opened Monday's show by admitting his football rooting interests are toast, and then he made the pitch.

Dave Portnoy
Dave Portnoy
@stoolpresidente

The bad news is my teams are dead. The good news is the people will get completely correct and unbiased football takes for the rest of the season

The "my teams are dead" part isn't a bit. The Patriots got run over 35-10 by the Lions in Munich on Sunday, and Drake Maye left in the 1st quarter after an Aidan Hutchinson sack. Ian Rapoport reports it's a significant lower leg injury, the Patriots are worried about a fractured ankle, and the Boston Globe says Maye could miss the rest of the season. Tommy DeVito played the rest of the game. Maye didn't even fly home with the team, per Mike Vrabel. So Dave has no rooting interest left and plenty of time for takes.

First up: the Chiefs. Dave thinks the whole country has written off Kansas City, and Sunday gave him a pretty good case. Patrick Mahomes went 22-of-35 for 348 yards and 5 touchdowns in a 35-13 beatdown of the Falcons.

Dave Portnoy
Dave Portnoy
@stoolpresidente

People are absolutely sleeping on the Chiefs this year

That was Mahomes' first 5-touchdown game since Week 1 of 2022 and the 7th of his career, which moves him past a tie for 4th-most all time. Only Drew Brees, Tom Brady and Peyton Manning have more. That's a guy who's alive and well, not cooked. So Dave put KC at No. 3, which is about as high as you can go and still say "people are sleeping on them" with a straight face.

Here's the full list: 1 Bills, 2 49ers, 3 Chiefs, 4 Jaguars, 5 Bears, 6 Vikings, 7 Broncos, 8 Rams, 9 Seahawks, 10 Bengals. The Bills at the top won't start many fights. Jacksonville at 4 and Chicago at 5 will. And the Lions aren't on the list, a day after they beat the brakes off his Patriots. Make of that what you will about "unbiased."

Then the hot take of the morning. Dave's argument is that the best evidence for Maye as MVP is how the Patriots looked once he was gone.

Dave Portnoy
Dave Portnoy
@stoolpresidente

Drake Maye might’ve shown he was the MVP yesterday with how inept the Patriots are without him

It's a very Boston way to make an MVP case, but it isn't crazy. New England scored 10 points in Germany, and from the moment the injury happened the whole season turned into a question of how long Maye is out. If the Globe's report holds and he's done for the year, Maye's MVP campaign ends with Dave's "look how bad they are without him" as the closing argument. Now that his own teams are out of it, Dave says the rest of his football takes will be neutral. We'll see how long that lasts.

Free Picks