Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State stun Arizona State in OT

By JR·2 min read
Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State stun Arizona State in OT

TLDR: Drew Mestemaker, who didn't start throwing until Thursday on a strained shoulder, went 30-of-40 for 294 yards as Oklahoma State erased a 17-point halftime hole to beat Arizona State 30-27 in overtime.

Nobody knew whether Oklahoma State's quarterback would play until the Cowboys ran out in Tempe. Then the word came down: he was starting.

Pete Thamel
Pete Thamel
@PeteThamel

Drew Mestemaker gets the start for Oklahoma State. He’d been dealing with a shoulder strain, which occurred in the first series of the Texas Tech game last week.

Pete Thamel
Pete Thamel
@PeteThamel

Here’s latest on a busy @CollegeGameDay on the injury front. t.co/qsyLGqLcYV

The first half went badly, and not all of it was the shoulder. Mestemaker was late and off target on a couple of throws, Julian Hugo got to him for a sack, and the Pokes kept punting. When OSU finally drove into Arizona State territory, Terrence Lewis had the ball ripped out of his hands for an interception that the people watching closest didn't put on the quarterback.

Marshall Scott
Marshall Scott
@MarshallScottOK

OSU drives into ASU territory, but then Mestemaker hits Lewis before a defender rips the ball out of his hands. Called an INT on the field, but that one certainly wasn't on Mestemaker.

Then Eric Morris made it worse. With 50 seconds left in the half, Mestemaker took an 11-yard sack on 3rd-and-1, and Morris called timeout with 47 seconds on the clock before he sent out the punt team. That gave the Sun Devils enough time to get the ball back, use both of their own timeouts, convert a 4th-and-10 and spike it with 5 seconds left. OSU went into the locker room down 17 and looked finished.

Whatever Morris said at halftime, it worked. By his own description it was a 'spirited' speech. OSU scored on its first 3 possessions of the second half while the defense forced 3 punts, and Caleb Hawkins, who'd been checked out on the sideline early in the game, walked in untouched from 7 yards to tie it.

DevilsDigest.com
DevilsDigest.com
@DevilsDigest

Q4 9:11 | OSU touchdown | 24-24 Caleb Hawkins went untouched on a seven-yard touchdown run to tie the game. The Cowboys have outgained and outscored the Sun Devils by 198 yards and 17 points in the second half. Scoring Drive: 10 plays, 75 yards, 05:37

Arizona State had one last chance to put it away and handled the clock in a strange way. Facing 4th-and-3 late, the Sun Devils ran the clock down, burned a timeout and kicked a 38-yard Carson Smith field goal to go up 27-24 with 3:12 left. That left Oklahoma State a lot of clock to work with.

Chris Karpman
Chris Karpman
@ChrisKarpman

Fourth and 3, ASU killed the clock and took a timeout. That may have been a strategic mistake.

OSU needed only some of it. Sam Keltner hit from 43 to tie it at 27 with 1:11 left. ASU then spent its last timeout on 4th-and-1 near midfield with 15 seconds left and still punted it away. Keltner opened overtime with a 35-yarder, and on Arizona State's first snap the Sun Devils dialed up a trick play from the OSU 25. Safety Quinton Hammonds was waiting for it.

Ben Hutchens
Ben Hutchens
@Ben_Hutchens_

OSU safety Quinton Hammonds on game-ending interception: “Might as well throw a hand out there and see if I could catch it and ended up catching it.” t.co/QIPwzZue4u

That one-handed pick finished a 20-3 second half and moved Oklahoma State to 7-4, 5-3 in the Big 12. The postgame news was how close Mestemaker came to not playing at all. Morris said Broderick Vehrs had taken every practice snap all week, and Mestemaker apologized to him.

Marshall Scott
Marshall Scott
@MarshallScottOK

Eric Morris said Broderick Vehrs took 100% of the snaps in practice this week. Drew Mestemaker said he apologized to Vehrs that he ended up playing.

Mestemaker said he didn't know he was playing until a few hours before kickoff. Then he completed 30 of 40 throws for 294 yards and brought OSU back from 17 down on the road.

Eric Bailey
Eric Bailey
@EricBaileyTW

Drew Mestemaker says he really didn't know if he was going to play or not until a few hours before the #OkState game. He didn't start throwing until Thursday and those passes were limited to about 10 yards.

Morris, to his credit, didn't hide from the timeout. He put the whole thing on himself, and it's easy to own it after you win.

Eric Bailey
Eric Bailey
@EricBaileyTW

Eric Morris took accountability. Respect. "Huge mistake by me. In my mind, we had dropped the snap & I had to call a timeout. I thought it was about to be third down & short. That can't happen. That's embarrassing on my part. Yeah, that's 1,000% on Coach Morris" #OkState

Eric Bailey
Eric Bailey
@EricBaileyTW

A first-half question: Why did #OkState call timeout after the third-and-1 sack lost 11 yards with 47 seconds left? A punt followed with the clock stopped. Arizona State had two timeouts left and used both on that final scoring drive before halftime. They ended with a FG.

Arizona State's regular season is over. Kenny Dillingham will be left thinking about how a dominant first half and a 17-point lead got away, along with a few clock decisions. Oklahoma State gets a week to rest Mestemaker's shoulder. The next question is whether he's throwing more than 10-yard passes in practice this time, or whether Vehrs takes every rep again.

Free Picks