Jim Hiller defends Gavin McKenna as Leafs lose 8 straight

By JR·2 min read
Jim Hiller defends Gavin McKenna as Leafs lose 8 straight

TLDR: Jim Hiller called Gavin McKenna ducking a hit a good decision and shrugged off questions about his own job after Toronto blew a 3-0 lead and lost an 8th straight game.

The fire started Thursday night, when the Kings came back to beat Toronto 4-3 in a shootout and the No. 1 overall pick never touched the ice in overtime.

McKenna hasn't played a second of OT all season. Hiller moved him up to the second line and the top power-play unit against LA, then gave him 14:28 of ice time. Asked about overtime, the coach said he wasn't sure the kid can make a play yet. Hockey Twitter took that personally. Chris Johnston called it a baffling explanation, and plenty of people pointed out that you don't take a guy 1st overall if you have doubts about whether he can make plays.

Spittin' Chiclets
Spittin' Chiclets
@spittinchiclets

“He's watched. We've had him up, and then called him off. He'll get out there eventually. But it's obviously a high-leverage time, and you need somebody who can make a play, and again I just want to make sure he's ready." Jim Hiller explains why he hasn’t played Gavin McKenna in OT.

It didn't help that the game got away in such ugly fashion. Toronto was up 3-0 early in the 2nd period and gave up 3 straight before the period ended. That loss dropped the Leafs to 8-13-3, with 10 losses in their last 11. The Kings, of all teams, were the ones who did it. LA fired Hiller earlier this year.

By Friday morning the columns were in. Daily Faceoff ran one that skipped the hedging completely and said that if the organization has any pride, Hiller has to go. Its core question is a simple one: what message do you send by accepting 8 straight losses, 7 of them at home?

Daily Faceoff
Daily Faceoff
@DailyFaceoff

If the Leafs organization has any pride, Jim Hiller has to go, writes @MLarkinHockey. "What message is sent if eight straight losses, and seven at home, are acceptable?" Column on the #PassionNeverSleeps: t.co/onpdhcrXY1

Then Toronto went in a direction nobody saw coming. The Leafs scrapped practice for an off-ice workout in the middle of a 9-games-in-17-days stretch and brought in Rory McIlroy and his sports psychologist, Dr. Bob Rotella. McIlroy had been at Thursday's game, which was his first NHL game ever, and stayed afterward to talk with Auston Matthews. Friday morning he and Rotella spent about 2 hours with the whole team, and Rotella also met with the coaching staff.

Elliotte Friedman
Elliotte Friedman
@FriedgeHNIC

This is the Sports Psychologist who, along with Rory McIlroy, met with Maple Leafs for approximately two hours this morning. Great book. McIlroy also met with Auston Matthews postgame last night while Rotella met with the coaching staff.

Elliotte Friedman: This is the Sports Psychologist who, along with Rory McIlroy, met with Maple Leafs for approximately two hours this morn

Hiller loved it. He called the session probably the most impactful thing they could get out of the day, with 2 of the best in the business spending time with his group. That's nice. A golfer still doesn't kill penalties, though. Hiller's other point is the one that actually holds up. Toronto has the NHL's worst points percentage,.136, since Kirill Marchenko got hurt in Calgary on Oct. 26, and Hiller says Marchenko is getting pretty close to a return.

Then the McKenna question came up again, this time about a clip of the rookie bailing out of a hit. This time Hiller backed his guy and called it a judgment call that might've been the right one. Steve Conroy made the same point, noting that Toronto kept the puck, which is the whole idea.

Mark Masters
Mark Masters
@markhmasters

Jim Hiller on this Gavin McKenna play: "He's gotta make that decision. If he feels vulnerable ... sometimes if you put yourself in a bad spot physically the outcome isn't very good. He has to continue to find that balance ... That might've been one where it's a good decision"

Leafs Papi
Leafs Papi
@LeafsPapi_

McKenna avoids the hit 😬 t.co/qAsdol476n

That's the strange part of Friday. On the hit, Hiller trusts McKenna's judgment. In overtime, he won't trust him to make a play. Asked about his job security, Hiller said it's "not something I think about too much." His bosses probably are thinking about it. If the Leafs drop a 9th straight in this part of the schedule, his answer about job security won't matter much. If Marchenko comes back and McKenna finally gets an OT shift, Hiller might buy himself some time.

Free Picks