Hunter Yurachek defends Alabama at No. 3, Indiana fumes

TLDR: CFP chair Hunter Yurachek says Alabama's schedule held up after 3 of its best wins lost, keeping the Tide at No. 3 a week after the same thing cost Indiana 5 spots.
Tuesday's rankings show opened with Rece Davis asking Yurachek the Indiana-Alabama question directly. The answer only made things worse.

#CFP chair and Arkansas AD Hunter Yurachek on Alabama: Said the impact of the losses of teams the Crimson Tide has beaten didn't affect its strength of schedule. "Credit to Alabama not playing their best on Saturday, and still finding a way to win."
Here's why that lands so badly. Last week Indiana, the defending national champs, sat on a bye and fell from No. 4 to No. 9. Yurachek's explanation then was that every Big Ten team the Hoosiers had beaten lost that weekend, and he called Indiana "the victim of having a bye week at the wrong time." This week the same thing happened to Alabama's resume, and the Tide didn't move at all after a 21-6 win at Vanderbilt that Yurachek himself admitted wasn't their best. ESPN noted it was the 4th straight game Alabama ran for fewer than 100 yards.
So the rule is that losses by the teams you beat sink your strength of schedule, unless the committee decides those teams were good enough that it doesn't count. That isn't a standard. It's a vibe. And the vibe keeps an 8-2 Alabama ahead of Tennessee, the team that beat them, and ahead of Texas, the team that beat Tennessee. All 3 have 2 losses.
Indiana did get something back. The Hoosiers jumped Tennessee and landed at No. 8, and Yurachek said the reason wasn't the resume. It was the offense.

Then Yurachek says Indiana jumped Tennessee because Indiana looked so impressive offensively against Southern Cal. "That's the thing that's been missing from Indiana all year, just a steady, consistent offense." #iufb
That's a weird way to say it about a team that was 9-1 and the reigning champ, but fine. Then people started looking further down the board, and that's when the conflict-of-interest talk took over. Yurachek isn't just the committee chair. He's the athletic director at Arkansas, and South Carolina somehow stayed ranked after losing to his team.

Conflict. Of. Interest. How does 6-4 South Carolina lose 34-6 at 3-6 Arkansas (Hunter Yurachek's school) and still wind up ranked?
For the record, there's no evidence Yurachek pulled any strings for the Gamecocks, and committee members recuse themselves on their own schools. But the optics are awful when the guy explaining the rankings runs an SEC athletic department and the explanations keep breaking toward the SEC. Plenty of beat writers on Tuesday said the same thing: sitting ADs shouldn't be anywhere near this room.
The line that should worry everyone outside the 2 big leagues came at the end, when Yurachek talked about how impressive the schedules of 4-loss SEC teams are.

Yurachek's final comment about 4-L teams from the SEC having impressive SOS is a warning flare for next year: SEC + Big Ten teams with 4L will get benefit of the doubt over 3L teams from the ACC + Big 12.
That's the real story beneath the Indiana anger. You can disagree, but the committee clearly thinks the SEC is just tougher, and it's going to keep ranking teams that way. There are only a couple of releases left before Selection Sunday, so watch what happens to Alabama the next time it doesn't cover. If the Tide slip up and still don't move, the Hoosiers won't be the only ones yelling.
More Stories
Indiana falls to No. 9 in CFP rankings, UCLA up to No. 4
Miami Hurricanes drop to No. 7 in CFP rankings
Brandon Walker rips Hunter Yurachek over Alabama No. 5
Seth Doege takes blame for Arizona fourth down vs. Utah
RJ Godfrey eligible for Arizona basketball after injunction
Jack Stivers flips to Kentucky from Western Kentucky


