JaMichael Stillwell beats NCAA, stays eligible at Texas Tech

TLDR: Judge John Grace granted JaMichael Stillwell a temporary injunction against the NCAA on Friday in Lubbock, so the forward stays eligible at Texas Tech, and the next open jury trial date is June 28, 2027.
Friday was a full day in court in Lubbock County, with 2 economists, a judge who kept pushing back on the NCAA, and Texas Tech's season riding on the result. It started with Stillwell showing up in person.
There were 3 parts to the hearing. First came the NCAA's special appearance, then its motion to vacate and sanction, and only after both of those failed would the court get to the injunction. Stillwell had already played under a temporary restraining order issued earlier in November and suited up for 3 of Tech's first 5 games. Friday decided whether that would continue.
The NCAA started by arguing that this was Stillwell's second eligibility case, not his first. It pointed to Godfrey v. NCAA in Georgia, where the Georgia Court of Appeals issued a stay. Then it made a strange argument. According to the NCAA, Texas Tech and other member schools have "interpretive discretion" over its rules, and the NCAA leaves eligibility up to the schools. Stillwell's side noted that NCAA representative Jerry Vaughn had testified that the NCAA does enforce its rules. Judge Grace didn't buy the discretion argument either.
Grace kept pressing. He said the bylaws have no wording that changes "by state," so the claim that every school reads the rules its own way didn't hold up. That was a bad sign for the NCAA before lunch.
The afternoon went to the economists, and it did not go quickly. Stillwell's lawyers had hoped to keep the whole hearing under 6 hours. Dr. Maxcy testified for Stillwell that the NCAA still holds monopsony power, basically a single buyer controlling the market, and that not much has changed since Alston. The NCAA questioned how he could weigh in on NIL pay when On3 has published only 42 verified amounts. It also argued that only one-and-done players are really valuable compared with older players. At one point the NCAA said it has to "draw the line somewhere" on eligibility, which is hard to square with its morning argument that eligibility is up to the schools.
Maxcy said he was supporting 5 years of eligibility under the new 5-for-5 rule, not 6, 7 or 8, and he finished by saying the rule violates antitrust law as applied to 2022 athletes. The NCAA's expert, Dr. Flyer, called Maxcy's analysis unreliable and argued that stricter eligibility would raise player pay. Under cross-examination, though, Flyer admitted he hadn't run his own analysis. In closing, Stillwell's side said Flyer just wanted to "throw rocks" at Maxcy's research.
Teammate Donovan Atwell, who won his own temporary injunction from the same judge with the same legal team, came to court for closing arguments. The NCAA's close came down to "these are the rules," plus the claim that every minute Stillwell plays takes a minute from another athlete. Stillwell's attorney Andrew Seger argued that the NCAA has given other athletes 5 years before but not players like Stillwell. He also said going after the Class of 2022 is creating chaos while the antitrust issues head to Congress. Then he delivered a closing line that drew attention in the courtroom.
Grace took a short recess to go over his notes and promised a ruling the same day. It took less than an hour.
Stillwell stays a Red Raider. Grace said the next available jury trial date is June 28, 2027, long after this season ends. Under the 5-for-5 rule, which was adopted August 1, Stillwell's lawyers argued that nothing in the NCAA's rules explicitly said the Class of 2022 was excluded. A judge has now agreed with that argument at least for now.
For now, Texas Tech keeps its forward and the NCAA has lost another one in Lubbock. Expect the NCAA to look for a stay or an appeal, as it did in Georgia. Until something changes, Stillwell keeps playing for Tech.
More Stories
AJ Criss commits to Texas Tech after West Virginia win
George MacIntyre injury update: available vs. LSU
Brady Hart to start over Marcel Reed for Texas A&M
A.J. Harris, Rolijah Hardy injury: out vs. Washington
Conner Weigman out, Keisean Henderson leads Houston win
AJ Randle at Miami visit as Notre Dame pushes for flip

