Mariners bet on Jason Kanzler, a manager who never managed

By JR·2 min read
Mariners bet on Jason Kanzler, a manager who never managed

TLDR: The Mariners made Jason Kanzler, the 36-year-old Cubs farm director who has never managed at any level, their new manager, picking him over former Astros skipper Joe Espada to replace Dan Wilson.

Most of the Pacific Northwest had to google the name when the scoop dropped Tuesday morning.

Seattle made it official later that day. Kanzler takes over for Dan Wilson, who got fired after a 76-86 season where a team people picked to contend missed the playoffs entirely. Cal Raleigh and Julio Rodriguez both struggled at the plate and the staff had the 6th-highest ERA in baseball after the All-Star break. That's the mess Kanzler inherits, and the front office looked at a finalist list that included Joe Espada, a guy who has actually managed in the big leagues, and went the other way.

The résumé is all development. Kanzler was a 20th-round pick as an outfielder in 2013, spent 5 years in the Houston organization, and was on the Astros' big-league coaching staff in 2022 and 2023, the last of those as assistant hitting coach. The Cubs made him their director of player development at the start of 2024, and he was in charge of the farm while guys like Pete Crow-Armstrong and Matt Shaw came through. That's a strong development record. It's still not a dugout.

And that's what makes the national guys nervous. Ken Rosenthal said straight out he was surprised, since he figured Seattle wanted experience, and 2 days later he went through exactly what the risk is.

Foul Territory
Foul Territory
@FoulTerritoryTV

“This guy has never managed at any level.” @Ken_Rosenthal breaks down the risk Seattle is taking by handing a veteran roster to first-time manager Jason Kanzler.

The two former catchers on the panel weren't buying it either. Their whole argument fits in one line: a roster built to win now needs a manager who's ready now, not one who's learning in the middle of a pennant race.

Foul Territory
Foul Territory
@FoulTerritoryTV

"You should hire a guy who's ready to win. Not a guy who needs to learn on the job." @AJPierzynski12 and @ErikKratz31 discuss whether Jason Kanzler is the right hire for the Mariners...

Seattle's case is that he wasn't a random swing. Jerry Dipoto said Kanzler has the mindset, communication skills and intensity to build a championship standard, and GM Justin Hollander said he showed elite leadership and an ability to connect with players, staff and the front office in his interviews. He also wasn't their first name, but the Mariners have been watching him for a long time.

Foul Territory
Foul Territory
@FoulTerritoryTV

Jason Kanzler wasn’t at the top of Seattle’s list, but he was far from a random choice. @A_Jude details the Mariners’ five-year history with their new manager.

Next comes the staff, and Kanzler says he'll have a say in it, calling it a completely collaborative effort with the front office. That's where this hire lives or dies. Give a first-time manager a bench coach who's been through the 162-game grind and Rosenthal's warning gets a lot quieter. Give him a staff of fellow development guys and every blown bullpen decision in May is going to hang on the 36-year-old in the No. 18 jersey. Dipoto bet on upside here. With Raleigh and Julio in their primes, Seattle doesn't have a lot of seasons to spend waiting for that upside to show up.

Free Picks
Jason Kanzler hired as Seattle Mariners manager