Avalanche claim Mike Reilly off waivers from Hurricanes

By JR·2 min read
Avalanche claim Mike Reilly off waivers from Hurricanes

TLDR: The Colorado Avalanche claimed 33-year-old defenseman Mike Reilly off waivers Sunday, a day after Carolina put him there to clear a roster spot for captain Jordan Staal's return from injured reserve.

The waiver wire moved fast on this one. Carolina put Reilly on waivers Saturday, and by Sunday afternoon the news was out.

Elliotte Friedman
Elliotte Friedman
@FriedgeHNIC

Colorado claims Reilly

Elliotte Friedman
Elliotte Friedman
@FriedgeHNIC

Reilly (CAR) & MacLean (NYI) on waivers

On the Carolina side, this is about the numbers. Staal partially tore his calf in warmups before an October 11 game in Philadelphia and missed 14 games. Getting the captain back meant somebody had to come off the 23-man roster. Reilly had been a frequent healthy scratch since mid-October, and with the Canes' blue line healthy again, he was the odd man out. He re-signed in September on a 1-year, 2-way deal paying $850K in the NHL and $450K in the AHL, so Carolina was taking a risk putting him on waivers. Colorado took him.

For the Avs, it's a no-brainer depth move. Reilly is a lefty, and his underlying numbers have been good pretty much everywhere he's played, even when his coaches didn't fully trust him.

Corey Masisak
Corey Masisak
@cmasisak22

Avs claimed defenseman Mike Reilly from the Hurricanes on waivers. He's a lefty with a consistent track record of good underlying numbers, even if he's been in some places where the coach didn't always trust him. Given the injuries, a solid, low-stakes bet.

"Given the injuries" is doing a lot of work there. Colorado just lost Nathan MacKinnon for about a month and Cale Makar for about 2 weeks, according to Pro Hockey Rumors. Nobody thinks Reilly replaces Makar. But when your best defenseman is out, you need bodies who can move the puck and not get caved in, and Reilly can do that. The money works too.

Corey Masisak
Corey Masisak
@cmasisak22

Reilly has also a couple of serious/scary injury situations in his career that have cut into his playing time. With Josh Manson already on LTIR, there's plenty of cap room to add a guy on a league-minimum deal.

Reilly has played for a lot of teams. Minnesota drafted him in 2011, and he's played for the Wild, Canadiens, Senators, Bruins, Panthers, Islanders and Hurricanes. His best stretch came with the Islanders in 2023-24, when he put up 23 points in 59 games averaging 17:16 a night. He also has a ring now. He played 2 playoff games and picked up 2 assists during Carolina's Cup run last spring. Avs fans had been expecting him to land in Denver for a while.

Evan Rawal
Evan Rawal
@evanrawal

Mike Reilly has felt like a future Avalanche depth defenseman the last few summers and now he is one.

Colorado had an open spot on the 23-man roster, so no corresponding move was needed, and Reilly can step straight into the lineup. It doesn't cost them anything, there's no long commitment, and he gives them another usable defenseman while MacKinnon and Makar are out. The thing to watch is whether he stays in the lineup when Makar comes back, or whether this is a short-term patch until the blue line is healthy again.

Free Picks
Mike Reilly claimed off waivers by Avalanche · Barstool Bush