Blue Jays decline Myles Straw's 2027 option

By JR·2 min read
Blue Jays decline Myles Straw's 2027 option

TLDR: The Blue Jays turned down Myles Straw's $8 million club option for 2027 and took the $1.75 million buyout, which makes the clubhouse favorite a free agent as the offseason opens.

The news hit Monday evening as free agency opened, and the Toronto beat had it within a minute of each other.

It isn't a shock on paper. Paying $8 million for a glove-first 4th outfielder is a lot, and the $1.75 million buyout barely costs Toronto anything. According to MLB.com, that buyout is covered by cash the Guardians sent over in the original trade. Cleveland is still paying Straw to leave town, which is a funny little bit of accounting.

Remember how he got here, too. Toronto traded for Straw before the 2025 season, and MLB.com says the deal was mostly about grabbing international bonus pool money to chase Roki Sasaki. That chase went nowhere. Straw was supposed to be the throw-in, then he forced his way onto the roster in 2025 Spring Training and became a guy coaches and teammates kept going out of their way to praise.

That's why this doesn't read like a clean break. A few minutes after breaking the news, Keegan Matheson made it pretty clear he doesn't think the door is shut.

That's a beat writer who's been around this team every day calling Straw one of the most well-liked players he's covered, and saying Straw has strong feelings about the organization. Read between the lines: declining the option is about the price, not the player. If Toronto can get him back on a cheaper deal once the bigger dominoes fall, both sides sound open to it.

There may well be a role, too. MLB.com notes the Blue Jays are staring at outfield depth questions with George Springer and Dalton Varsho heading out. A defense-first outfielder who can play all 3 spots and who the room already loves is exactly the kind of guy who gets a call in January when the market cools.

So for now Straw is a free agent, and he'll find out what the rest of the league thinks a speed-and-defense outfielder is worth. Keep an eye on Toronto once the big outfield names sign. If Matheson is right, this could end with Straw back in the clubhouse at a fraction of $8 million.

Free Picks
Myles Straw free agent after Blue Jays decline option