Nicky Smokes explains going third-person after Ebony episode backlash

By JR·2 min read
Nicky Smokes explains going third-person after Ebony episode backlash

TLDR: Nicky Smokes' Out&AboutPod sitdown with Ebony over his history with female coworkers blew up online, and instead of laying low he went full third-person defending how he tags his own social clips.

Nicky Smokes has built his whole Barstool identity on being the office's resident wild card, and this week's Out&AboutPod episode with Ebony put that reputation right back in the spotlight. The sitdown, which had Pat and Kelly Keegs pressing him on his dating behavior with female coworkers before Ebony joined to air her own grievances, was always going to get a reaction. It got one fast.

Stoolies Clubhouse 🏴‍☠️
Stoolies Clubhouse 🏴‍☠️
@StooliesClub

This interview was WILD! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Viva La Stool
Viva La Stool
@VivaLaStool

HOT start to the Smokes and Ebony segment! t.co/Orf9Nj4wJa

Clips ricocheted around Barstool Twitter for a full day, and by Tuesday night the story had a second act: how Nicky Smokes was handling the fallout himself. Viva La Stool flagged that on his own Instagram, he'd started referring to himself in the third person, both in the caption and inside the video itself, rather than posting it like a normal personal update.

Viva La Stool
Viva La Stool
@VivaLaStool

On instagram Nicky Smokes went 3rd person in the caption and on the video

Viva La Stool: On instagram Nicky Smokes went 3rd person in the caption and on the video
Viva La Stool
Viva La Stool
@VivaLaStool

“It’s my favorite soap opera Nicky and Annika” -Keegs t.co/dnZxu7ol8O

That's a notable tell for anyone who's watched him get bigger online, and Nicky didn't dodge the question when it got asked directly. He came back with an actual explanation instead of playing it off, framing the third-person bit as a deliberate strategy rather than an ego thing.

Nicky Smokes
Nicky Smokes
@nickysmokess

@VivaLaStool @OutandAboutpod @barstoolsports @BarstoolPAT @kellykeegs Should I have put “barstool employee” like every social clip😂 Reels/Tiktok shows your videos to more non followers than followers. People don’t look at the account on reels/tik tok. Might as well put my name.

His logic tracks with how Reels and TikTok actually distribute content: those platforms shove clips in front of people who've never followed the account, so a caption assuming familiarity does nothing. Saying his own name, or a tag like 'barstool employee,' is a play for the algorithm's cold audience rather than the people already in the replies. It's a small, practical answer to what looked like a bigger ego story.

Stoolies Clubhouse 🏴‍☠️
Stoolies Clubhouse 🏴‍☠️
@StooliesClub

@nickysmokess @VivaLaStool @OutandAboutpod @barstoolsports @BarstoolPAT @kellykeegs Not the worst idea I’ve ever heard honestly 🤝

Nicky Smokes got hired after winning a high-stakes Game 7 bet against Dave Portnoy with only around 8,000 Twitter followers to his name, and he's leaned into being the office wild card ever since. Turning a backlash cycle into a matter-of-fact explainer about social media strategy is on brand for someone who's clearly thinking about his own algorithm as much as his own reputation. Whether that satisfies the coworkers he's actually addressed in the episode is a different question, and one Out&AboutPod will almost certainly keep circling back to.

Free Picks