Big Cat and PFT Commenter reignite Barstool's cannoli war

By JR·2 min read
Big Cat and PFT Commenter reignite Barstool's cannoli war

TLDR: Pardon My Take's Mount Rushmore of Masculine Foods segment turned into a full-blown cannoli pile-on, with Big Cat trashing Italian dessert and half of Barstool piling in behind him.

Pardon My Take's Mount Rushmore segment is usually harmless bar-stool debate: steak versus ribs, burgers versus wings, the kind of stuff that gets argued and forgotten by the next episode. Not this time. Big Cat and PFT Commenter's August 10 show, taped with Pro Football Talk's Mike Florio, built out a Mount Rushmore of Masculine Foods, and somewhere in the discussion Big Cat decided cannolis needed to be publicly executed.

Barstool Sports
Barstool Sports
@barstoolsports

“Italians don’t do dessert well” -Big Cat

"Italians don't do dessert well" is a fighting-words sentence on a show with Italian-American hosts and an Italian-American fan base, and it landed exactly like you'd expect. PFT Commenter followed it up by literally putting a cannoli on camera and giving it the taste test, mouth agape, verdict written all over his face before he even asked the question out loud.

Cons wasted no time turning it into vindication. He's apparently been saying cannolis stink for a while and getting grief for it, and now he's got Big Cat on record backing him up on the flagship show.

Cons
Cons
@CaptainCons

It’s come to my attention that @BarstoolBigCat shared this same sentiment on @PardonMyTake today Cannolis stink. Italians stink at dessert Now maybe some of you will get off my back

From there it was a full dogpile. Pat called cannolis an "F-tier dessert," though he gave Italians a pass because the rest of the food is that good. Jack Kennedy went further and torched the entire cream-filling category, not just cannolis. The Wonton Don, predictably, used the moment to pitch his own crab-and-cream-cheese agenda. Zah, on the other hand, wanted Big Cat and PFT nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize just for saying it out loud, which tells you how split the room actually was.

Two days later, the show doubled down instead of walking it back. Pardon My Take posted the full Mount Rushmore graphic from the segment, breaking out the masculine-foods board across three columns of steak, ribs, bacon, wings, sausage and the rest, and asked the crowd what got left off. Cannoli, notably, wasn't anywhere near the mountain.

Pardon My Take
Pardon My Take
@PardonMyTake

The Mount Rushmore of Most Masculine Foods What got left off the list? @krakenfx

It's a Mount Rushmore segment doing exactly what a Mount Rushmore segment is designed to do: pick a dumb hill, plant a flag, and let the replies do the rest of the work. Big Cat and PFT Commenter have run this format for years precisely because the arguments never actually resolve — they just get louder every time someone brings up cannolis again.

Free Picks