Princewill Umanmielen, Devin Harper fire back at Ole Miss

Ole Miss sued its 2 former players for buyout money months ago. On Friday, the players gave their answer, and it wasn't an apology.
That is a full counterpunch. Umanmielen isn't just arguing over the number. He's saying the contract itself is tainted because coaches pushed him into signing it, and that he can't get a fair shake in Oxford. "Unclean hands" is a legal phrase, but the meaning is clear enough: you don't get to collect on a deal you leaned on a kid to sign.
Here's what got us here. Ole Miss filed suit in Lafayette County in late July, claiming Umanmielen owes $550,000 in buyout money for leaving early on his revenue-sharing agreement. Harper got hit with a separate $400,000 claim. Ole Miss is chasing close to $1 million from 2 players who followed Lane Kiffin to Baton Rouge after his ugly exit from Oxford.
About an hour after the first report, it stopped being just Umanmielen's case.
Same lawyer, same filing, same day. These were always 2 separate lawsuits, but now they're 1 coordinated defense. Whatever argument wins for Umanmielen almost certainly wins for Harper too, and the reverse is just as true. Ole Miss isn't picking off 2 players one at a time anymore. It's fighting 1 legal theory about whether these revenue-share buyouts hold up at all.
Ole Miss hasn't exactly played this one quietly either. The school had Umanmielen served with court papers in the parking lot of LSU's football facility in September, days before the Tigers played in Oxford. Ole Miss has also asked LSU to cover the buyouts. LSU said no, pointing out that it was never a party to the contracts.
This is bigger than an SEC grudge match. Revenue sharing is brand new, and these buyout clauses were supposed to be the thing that stopped players from walking out the door the minute a coach leaves. If a court decides a deal signed under pressure from coaches can't be enforced, or that Oxford is the wrong place to hear the case, every school that wrote these clauses into its contracts has a problem.
Up next is the fight over venue. If the cases get moved out of Lafayette County, that's an early win for the players before anyone even argues the merits. Ole Miss built these contracts to scare people out of leaving. Now it gets to find out whether they hold up in court.
More Stories
Devin Lavalais commits to LSU, flips from Tulane
Nigel Newkirk flips from Alabama to Ohio State
Dorian Williams commits to Miami, JUCO offensive tackle
Brauntae Johnson injury update: Notre Dame safety vs. SMU
Whit Weeks injury update: questionable for LSU vs. Texas
Greg Harbaugh fired as Minnesota offensive coordinator

