Bill Belichick among 5 Hall of Fame coach finalists

By JR·2 min read
Bill Belichick among 5 Hall of Fame coach finalists

TLDR: Bill Belichick, Tom Coughlin, Mike Holmgren, Dan Reeves and Mike Shanahan are the 5 coaches still alive for the Hall of Fame's Class of 2027, and only 1 survives Nov. 17.

Here we go again. A year after the Hall somehow didn't let Belichick in, the coaches' list is out and his name is on it once more.

Adam Schefter
Adam Schefter
@AdamSchefter

Five former head coaches - Bill Belichick, Tom Coughlin, Mike Holmgren, Dan Reeves and Mike Shanahan - have advanced in the process for possible election to the Pro Football Hall of Fame’s Class of 2027.

Adam Schefter: Five former head coaches - Bill Belichick, Tom Coughlin, Mike Holmgren, Dan Reeves and Mike Shanahan - have advanced in

Here's how it works. Being 1 of 5 coach nominees doesn't get you to Canton. The Hall's coach subcommittee meets virtually on Nov. 17 and sends exactly 1 of these 5 to the full selection committee. That coach joins 13 players and 1 contributor in a pool of 15 finalists. So for 4 of these guys, it's over in 12 days.

Albert Breer
Albert Breer
@AlbertBreer

The @ProFootballHOF has announced its five coach nominees. • Bill Belichick • Tom Coughlin • Mike Holmgren • Dan Reeves • Mike Shanahan The coaches subcommittee meets Nov. 17 to pick one to go into a pool of 15 finalists, which will include one contributor and 13 players.

Belichick should be the easiest call in the history of the building. He won 6 Super Bowls as the Patriots head coach and 2 more as a defensive assistant with the Giants. He was among the coaching candidates last year too and didn't get elected, and that snub became one of the bigger football stories of the offseason. Spygate is the only argument anybody can make against him. He's in his second season coaching North Carolina now, which somehow makes it feel even weirder that he's waiting on a phone call.

That's what everybody is wondering, and it's a fair question, because the other 4 aren't filler. Tom Coughlin won 2 Super Bowls with the Giants, both over Belichick's Patriots, and went 182-157 over 20 seasons between Jacksonville and New York. Mike Holmgren won a ring with Brett Favre's Packers and then took Seattle to a Super Bowl. Mike Shanahan won back-to-back titles in Denver with John Elway. Dan Reeves won 201 games and took 4 teams to the Super Bowl, but went 0-4 once he got there.

That's the trap with a 1-coach bottleneck. Every year somebody deserving gets left in line, and Coughlin and Shanahan have been waiting a long time. But you can't jump anyone ahead of the guy with 6 rings as a head coach. If the subcommittee picks anybody other than Belichick on Nov. 17, the Hall has a credibility problem that writes itself.

Even if he gets through, it's not done. The full selection committee votes later, each voter picks up to 6 candidates, and a finalist needs 80% support to get in. The Class of 2027 gets announced in February at NFL Honors. Nov. 17 is just the first step, but it's the one that tells us if the voters learned anything from last year.

Free Picks