Project Big Screen splits on Tom Cruise's Digger

By JR·2 min read
Project Big Screen splits on Tom Cruise's Digger

TLDR: Project Big Screen's Digger review ran from 'painfully unfunny' to 'FIVE STARS,' and the crew's group ranking of Tom Cruise's 10 best performances left Rain Man out entirely, much to Chris Klemmer's horror.

The movie came in pre-divided. The panel didn't do much to settle it.

Project Big Screen
Project Big Screen
@ProjBigScreen

“One of the wildest mix of feelings I’ve had watching a movie” @JeffDLowe “Thinks it’s the smartest guy in the room” @ChrisKlemmer “Painfully unfunny” @JackKennedy “FIVE STARS” @bobgoochman Our most divisive review yet…. What did you think of #DIGGER starring Tom Cruise?

That's about as wide as a 4-person panel can spread. @JeffDLowe called it 'one of the wildest mix of feelings I've had watching a movie,' Chris Klemmer said it 'thinks it's the smartest guy in the room,' @JackKennedy went with 'painfully unfunny,' and @bobgoochman gave it 5 stars. The show called it its most divisive review yet, and when a follower summed it up as 'polarizing and memorable,' @JeffDLowe answered with a 1-word 'Yes.'

The real critics landed in the same place. Digger is Alejandro G. Iñárritu's satirical black comedy, with Cruise playing Texas oil tycoon Digger Rockwell, and The Hollywood Reporter flat-out called the reviews 'brutally split.' The raves are huge and the pans are vicious. Variety said Cruise goes 'over the top' in a 'bombastically self-important satire.' Even a lot of the pans single out the performance, though, and that's the hook for the second half of the episode.

Project Big Screen
Project Big Screen
@ProjBigScreen

Is Tom Cruise’s performance in DIGGER the best of his career? @bobgoochman says YES What do you think the #1 turn from the iconic movie star? We collaboratively rank our Top 10 and review the wildly divisive film on today’s episode

@bobgoochman doesn't just like it. He says it's the best thing Cruise has ever done. That's a big claim for a guy whose filmography runs from Top Gun to Jerry Maguire to Magnolia to Collateral to a whole lot of Mission: Impossible. So the crew built a group top 10 of Cruise's best performances, and that's where things went sideways.

Project Big Screen
Project Big Screen
@ProjBigScreen

“It’s one of the best performances of the 80s! That’s MADNESS.” @ChrisKlemmer was stunned to find out Tom Cruise’s turn in RAIN MAN didn’t crack the Top 10 in our collaborative ranking of the actor’s greatest performances of his career

Rain Man didn't make it. Klemmer took it about as well as you'd expect, calling it 'one of the best performances of the 80s' and the snub 'MADNESS.' He's got a case. Cruise is the straight man opposite Dustin Hoffman's Oscar-winning turn and does a lot of the quiet work that makes that movie function. The show joked the next day that the ranking 'may have broken' him, and Born on the Fourth of July came up in that clip too. It's a list where Cruise's actual Oscar-nominated roles have to fight with stunt-era Ethan Hunt for spots.

The show also posted the full math, so you can check who sank Rain Man yourself.

Project Big Screen
Project Big Screen
@ProjBigScreen

Voting Breakdown:

Project Big Screen: Voting Breakdown:

So the open question is whether Digger gets a spot on a Cruise list like this a year from now or ends up as the weird one critics fought over for a week. The crew wants your top 3. If it doesn't have Rain Man on it, maybe don't send it to Klemmer.

Free Picks