Rico Bosco meets newest enemy in Pick Em Week 5

TLDR: Week 5 of Barstool Pick Em dropped September 30 with Rico Bosco coming face to face with a brand new enemy, while a sick Dave Portnoy called it his literal flu game.
A week after the show was already billing Rico's latest arch-enemy, Pick Em found him another one. This one showed up by phone video.
It's a bit, and it's the best kind of Rico bit, because nobody on this show needs much of an excuse to pick a fight. The man in the video brings up Princeton, the guy in the Bosco shirt takes it personally, and that's all it took for the newest name on Rico's enemies list. That list was already long. On Week 4 the hook was Rico's beef with Ed, and Dave was pitching a rebrand for Rico's own event in the middle of it.
“It honestly should be the lunatic ball. Like that would be a better name for that event. Rico Bosco's lunatic ball.” – Dave Portnoy
Then there was Dave, who was in no shape to referee anything. He came in looking like he'd been hit by a truck, and when Big Cat asked how he was doing, Prez skipped right past calling a doctor and diagnosed himself.

“Dave how ya feelin?” -Big Cat “Self-diagnosis, I think I have pneumonia” -Dave
Dave's own name for it was his literal flu game, which is a lot of Michael Jordan to put on a college football picks show. Flu or not, he still had it in him to roast Mut's face paint. When Rico asked what he thought of it, all Dave gave him was "I liked the effort." Being sick didn't calm Rico down either. Rico apparently blew up at Big Cat after someone brought up his dinner with Jerry and the Anus boys.

Not really sure why but Rico jumped down Big Cats throat here after his dinner with Jerry and the Anus boys got brought up
That dinner isn't some random reference. Rico and Jerry have been working on the friendship on the Jerry and Terry Show, and Rico has even pitched a home-and-home that ends with the two of them at an Alabama game. Bring it up on Pick Em, though, and apparently it's a fight. The show's own account also picked up a running theme. Another week, another employee talking to Rico like a child.

Another week, another employee talking to Rico like a child…seems to be a trend here
The child bit had already been going for days. On the Yak on 2026-09-28, Big Cat was declaring curses on anyone who goes after Rico this way.
“That's an official curse that counts... you talking to him like a child, you have not won a game since.” – Big Cat
So that's where things stand after 5 weeks. Rico has a new enemy every week, Dave is self-diagnosing on air and the staff keep talking to Rico like he's in the 3rd grade. The picks almost come second, which is how it should be. Watch next week for whether the Princeton guy takes a real seat at the table, and whether Dave makes it through the episode without needing an ambulance.
More Stories
Rico Bosco Air Force -23.5 bet covers in 52-3 win over UTEP
Jon Gruden hangs up on Sam Darnold caller in Week 11 show
Steven Cheah watches Marvel movies for the first time
Fiona the hippo dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing hat
Barstool Greg misses flight, Burns takes off without him
Ohio's Tate owes 31 cans of corn after Ohio State loss



