Cardinals eliminated from playoffs for 4th straight year

By JR·2 min read
Cardinals eliminated from playoffs for 4th straight year

TLDR: St. Louis closed the books on October before Labor Day even faded.

  1. Fri Sep 189:59 PM CT

    The Number Goes Final

    It had been coming for weeks, but it became official during the Nationals series at Busch: the Cardinals are done for 2026, eliminated from the NL Wild Card race with the Padres locking up the last spot. It's the 4th straight year St. Louis misses October -- the longest active drought the franchise has had since the 1990s.

    Foul Territory
    Foul Territory
    @FoulTerritoryTV

    The St. Louis Cardinals have been eliminated from playoff contention.

    Foul Territory: The St. Louis Cardinals have been eliminated from playoff contention.

    Derrick Goold, who's covered this team through every version of this era, put a number on just how long this stretch has dragged on for a franchise that used to treat the postseason as a birthright.

  2. Finding The Silver Lining

    Once a season is mathematically over, the story shifts to what's next, and the Cardinals have been leaning hard into that pivot. Front office and beat coverage both framed 2026 as a clarifying year even in defeat -- and the attendance ledger became part of that pitch. After a brutal two-year slide that saw the largest ticket-sales decline in baseball in both 2024 and 2025, the front office is touting 2026 as the year the bleeding stopped.

    That stabilization lines up with real changes at Busch -- the team rolled out a $5 value menu and the $29 'Coca-Cola Unlimited' all-you-can-eat section this year specifically to address the affordability complaints that had been driving fans away. It's not a boom, but after two years of freefall, holding steady counts as a win in its own right. Meanwhile the on-field storyline for 2027 is already being written in real time, and not every part of it is smooth -- rookie Quinn Mathews has been open about fighting his swing in public as he tries to hold down a job.

  3. Last Call At Busch

    None of the elimination math stopped the Cardinals from playing their final home date of the year like it mattered. Ivan Herrera stayed hot late, tying the game with a 439-foot blast -- his second multi-homer game of the season and third of his career, a reminder of the power the roster is building around heading into next year.

    With the season already decided, the vibe around the ballpark turned toward next October instead of this one. Riley O'Brien came in to lock down a 2-run lead in the 9th, and Goold's framing of the moment doubled as a farewell to the building for the winter.

    Leo Bernal supplied the go-ahead knock, and O'Brien finished it off with help from Victor Scott II in the field, closing out a 5-3 win and the home slate for 2026 on a high note despite the bigger picture.

    So the Cardinals head into the winter with a losing record, a 4th straight playoff miss and a lot of questions about the front office's next move -- but also with two rookies who look like part of the answer and a fan base that, for now, has stopped walking away. Whether that's real progress or just a plateau gets sorted out next spring.

Free Picks