Super Critics hits Spider-Man 2 with Tom Scibelli

TLDR: Super Critics finally reached Spider-Man 2 (2004), and Robbie Fox calls it arguably the biggest day in the show's history, with Tom Scibelli joining him and Chris Klemmer to break it down.
Super Critics has been working through superhero movies in order, and the Sam Raimi era finally caught up with Robbie Fox. He did not undersell it.

Today is arguably the biggest day in Super Critics history, as we're finally up to SPIDER-MAN 2 in 2004! @TomScibelli joins me and @ChrisKlemmer to break down one of the most iconic superhero movies ever made!
"Arguably the biggest day in Super Critics history" is a big claim from a show that has already done Superman (1978) and Batman (1989). But if any movie from that run earns it, it's this one. Spider-Man 2 came out June 30, 2004, with Raimi directing, Tobey Maguire back as Peter Parker and Alfred Molina playing Doc Ock. It made $797 million worldwide and won the Oscar for Best Visual Effects. Plenty of people still call it the best Spider-Man movie, or the best superhero movie, period.
Bringing in Tom Scibelli makes it a 3-man episode, and Scibelli came with trivia. In one clip the hosts get to the subway train scene, the one where the passengers carry an unmasked Spider-Man over their heads after he stops the train. Scibelli says Maguire's own half brothers are in it.

Did you know Tobey Maguire's half brothers make a cameo in Spider-Man 2? @TomScibelli brings the facts on Super Critics!
Scibelli's fact holds up. According to Spider-Man 2 trivia lists, the 2 boys who hand Peter his mask back on the train are Maguire's half brothers, Weston Epp and Jopaul Epp. One of them tells Peter "We won't tell nobody." Most people have seen the scene a dozen times without knowing that, which makes it good podcast material.
The subway scene is pretty much where this movie lives. Peter is barely standing, a train full of strangers sees his face, and nobody gives him up. It's the moment people point to when they argue Raimi's Spider-Man 2 is the best of the genre, so it makes sense that a whole stretch of the episode went to it.
For a show built on ranking and arguing over every superhero movie, this episode was always going to be a test. Super Critics has Superman and Batman behind it, and now Spider-Man 2 sets the bar for the rest of the 2000s. Spider-Man 3 is coming up on the list at some point, and it won't get treated anywhere near as kindly.
More Stories
Tommy Smokes The Apartment weekly live show
Steven Cheah watches Marvel movies for the first time
Barstool Greg misses flight, Burns takes off without him
Stu Feiner hypes Fasoli wedding seat next to Dave Portnoy
Paul Bissonnette Peakin episode at Mount Washington
Nicky Smokes GTA 6 reaction on release day


