Lewis Kelly loses the Survivor 51 coin flip

By JR·2 min read
Lewis Kelly loses the Survivor 51 coin flip

TLDR: Lewis Kelly became the first Survivor player ever sent home by the million-dollar coin flip in episode 9 of Survivor 51, and the Snuffin Torches crew is still fuming about it.

Lewis was the guy nobody could beat in a challenge this week. Turns out that was the problem.

Tommy Smokes
Tommy Smokes
@TomScibelli

Lewis proving a golden rule of Survivor: Never be TOO good in reward challenges #Survivor51

In "Wilder Than a Cat in a Bathtub," which aired Wednesday, Lewis basically won the slingshot reward challenge for the purple team by himself. That got them a helicopter tour and a Fijian picnic, and it also made him the obvious target. Devin was blunt with him about being a threat, and the 2 of them went back and forth at Tribal over who would take the coin flip. Lewis took it. Probst brought the twist back for the first time since Season 50, with fire on one side of the coin and water on the other. Win, and you get safety, an immunity idol and a pot that doubles to $2 million. Lose, and you're out on the spot with no vote. Lewis called fire. It landed on water. Game over.

John Rich
John Rich
@JohnRichTV

By far the biggest problem with the million-dollar coin flip is you know what's gonna happen based on how much time is left in the episode When Lewis flipped that coin at 9:25 you knew he was cooked #Survivor51

John Rich's complaint is the real one with this twist. Survivor is still a TV show cut to fit an hour, so when the coin goes up at 9:25 with 5 minutes left, you can guess how it ends. Tommy Smokes and BarstoolNate went live with Snuffin Torches right after the episode to break down the flip, and the full recap was posted everywhere Thursday. Then Nate found something that made it worse.

Eric Nathan
Eric Nathan
@BarstoolNate

How can this be true? Jeff Probst should be in prison. Outrageous.

Survivor Mothers
Survivor Mothers
@survivormothers

So Lewis’ coin flip originally landed on fire, but because it didn’t land in the circle he had to reflip and got eliminated… that’s so dumb #Survivor51

Take "Jeff Probst should be in prison" for what it is: Nate doing a bit. What set him off is a contestant casually saying on a podcast that something had to be done a second time. That stings more when one toss decides a man's whole game. To be clear, none of the episode recaps we read mention a redo of Lewis' flip. What aired was one call, fire, and one result, water. For now, the do-over is something Survivor fans are talking about, not something the show has said happened.

There was plenty of other madness in the episode. Erik never used the Extra Vote and handed it back to Cristian after Tribal. Tommy called it one of the dumbest moves he's ever seen, not some secret masterplan. Over at camp, Devin made a fake idol and planted it for Maggie, then spent the episode trying to steer her to it.

Tommy Smokes
Tommy Smokes
@TomScibelli

Nobody has ever refused to find an idol more than Maggie just now. "I don't know, a leaf?" That was some A+ comedy #Survivor51

Maggie flat out would not pick up the idol, even after Devin went and got it himself. Lewis, meanwhile, is out of the game. The coin had never sent anyone home until him, and after his exit interviews he comes off as someone who'd flip it again. For the rest of the season, keep an eye on whether Probst brings the coin back and whether the edit gives away the result again. Also watch whether anyone at CBS explains what the podcast clip is getting at. Until then, Snuffin Torches will keep the outrage going every week.

Free Picks