Cole looks like Cole again and the Yankees have a rotation

By JR·2 min read
Cole looks like Cole again and the Yankees have a rotation

TLDR: Gerrit Cole carved Kansas City on 79 pitches, Benny came up huge with the bases loaded, and suddenly the Yankees' top 3 looks like something special.

For a guy who spent over a year on the couch, Gerrit Cole sure didn't look like he needed a ramp-up period. 6.2 innings, 4 hits, 0 runs, 0 walks, 10 strikeouts, 79 pitches against the Royals. That's not a rehab line. That's the version of Cole that won a Cy Young, just with a more economical approach and a changeup he's actually willing to throw.

Eric Hubbs
Eric Hubbs
@BarstoolHubbs

Zero control issues tonight for Cole. Mixed in way more off speed pitches, including that changeup which was super effective. Just breezed through this Royals lineup 6.2 IP | 4 H | 0 R | 0 BB | 10 K | 79 pitches | Boy is it good to have this guy back

The vibe in real time was basically people laughing at how easy he was making it look. Royals hitters had no chance, the pitch count never threatened, and Cole was out there genuinely upset they wouldn't let him camp under an infield pop. It was a vintage outing dressed up in a slightly more grown-up package — fewer max-effort fastballs, more mixing, same dominance.

Eric Hubbs
Eric Hubbs
@BarstoolHubbs

Anyone else just watching Cole pitch and laughing?

Cole wasn't the only one cooking. Ben Rice — Benny — came up with the bases loaded and 2 outs and did exactly what you want your guy to do in that spot, pushing what was already a comfortable lead into a laugher. Two-out, bases-loaded hits are the kind of swing that flips a game from "in control" to "foot on the gas," and the Yankees have been desperate for more of those.

Eric Hubbs
Eric Hubbs
@BarstoolHubbs

Two out hits with the bases loaded are so good for the soul Benny is such a pal

Zoom out and the bigger story here is the rotation. Schlittler, Cole, Fried as a top 3 is, depending on who you ask, the best the Yankees have run out there in 10 or 15 years. That's not a small claim for a franchise that's churned through a lot of arms, and it reframes how this team should be thinking about the next 2 months. The bullpen is still the open wound — Cruz, Reyzelman, Lagrange, ERC, whoever — but if the front office figures out which young arms are real and treats the deadline like it matters, this rotation gives them a real shot.

Eric Hubbs
Eric Hubbs
@BarstoolHubbs

The Yankees starting rotation is genuinely special. The 1-2-3 of Schlittler, Cole, and Fried is the best we've had in what? 10 years? 15? More? They MUST solve the bullpen. If the plan is internally you gotta get young arms up here and see what they got. Cruz, Reyzelman, Lagrange, ERC, someone I'm missing? Figure out who can contribute in 2026 and address the rest at the deadline. You wanna see them be aggressive? Start figuring this out soon with two months to go til the deadline. Longer you wait the harder it gets.

And file this one away for later: if the Yankees actually go on a run from here, circle Anthony Volpe's 9th-inning hit on Monday as the moment things turned. The AL Central schedule helped, the Rays losing helped, but momentum is a real thing in May and right now the Yankees finally have some. 34-22 and breathing again.

Free Picks