Florida State-Miami has been decided by single digits in three of the last five meetings. This year the talent gap looks bigger than it has in a decade.
Bush’s Picks
FSUMIA
FSUMIA
OverUnder
Best BetMiami
Miami is the far more complete team on paper right now — a top-8 preseason roster with a proven transfer quarterback against a Florida State squad breaking in a new starter and offensive line for a third straight year. Back the Hurricanes to win outright; the roster and quarterback edges are too significant to fade. The one thing keeping this off a lock tier is that this rivalry has produced its share of upsets regardless of talent gaps.
Florida State
+Duce Robinson coming off 1,000-yard season
+Ashton Daniels brings 23 career P4 starts
+Some national voices tab FSU a sleeper
−Third straight year breaking in new starting QB
−Rebuilding entire offensive line again
−7-18 since 2023 CFP snub
Miami
+Preseason top-8 team, CFP-lock buzz nationally
+Deepest, most talented roster in 20 years
+Mensah arrives off ACC title, 3,973 yards, 34 TDs
−Mensah unproven in new system, new supporting cast
−Replacing Beck's 3,813-yard, 30-TD production is tall order
−Rivalry has a history of upsetting the favorite
Miami handed its offense to Darian Mensah this offseason, and the résumé explains why nobody blinked. The Duke transfer threw for 3,973 yards and 34 touchdowns while dragging the Blue Devils to their first ACC Championship since 1989, and now he's stepping into a Hurricanes program with more talent around him than Duke ever had. Florida State counters with its own portal answer at quarterback in Ashton Daniels, the Auburn and Stanford transfer who beat out Kevin Sperry this spring for a starting job that's now churned through a new face for three straight seasons.
The gap isn't just at quarterback. Miami is running out what's being called its deepest, most talented roster in 20 years under Mario Cristobal, while Florida State is replacing its entire offensive line for the second year running behind Daniels. The Seminoles aren't devoid of juice — Duce Robinson is coming off a 1,000-yard season and, paired with Micahi Danzy, gives new OC Tim Harris a receiver duo that could hang with almost anyone. Mike Norvell is also handing over play-calling to Harris while staying hands-on, a wrinkle worth watching as the staff tries to find its footing early.
Show fees
11:00 PM CT
Spread
ML
Total
FSU Florida State
MIA Miami
This series has a way of not caring about the talent gap on paper. Miami leads the all-time series 37-33, but Florida State ripped off wins in 2021, 2022 and 2023 before the Hurricanes snapped back with a 36-14 statement in 2024. Whichever way this one breaks, it's the latest chapter in one of the sport's nastiest in-state rivalries, and it lands with Miami's national title hopes squarely on the line.
Florida State Seminoles
Oct 9?@ Louisville—
Oct 2?vs Virginia—
Sep 25?vs Central Arkansas—
Sep 19?@ Alabama—
Sep 7?vs SMU—
Aug 29?vs New Mexico State—
Miami Hurricanes
Oct 2?@ Clemson—
Sep 26?vs Central Michigan—
Sep 18?@ Wake Forest—
Sep 10?vs Florida A&M—
Sep 4?@ Stanford—
Recent form.
The preseason buzz around Miami is about as loud as it gets outside the sport's true blue bloods — multiple outlets have the Hurricanes around No. 7 or No. 8 nationally, with some analysts calling them a near-lock for the College Football Playoff field. Florida State, meanwhile, is stuck in the opposite conversation: four missed postseasons in six years and a 7-18 record since the program's infamous 2023 CFP snub, even as a few national voices float the Seminoles as a sleeper if the offensive rebuild clicks faster than expected.
Florida State Seminoles
(0)
Fully healthy — no injuries on ESPN's report
Miami Hurricanes
(0)
Fully healthy — no injuries on ESPN's report
Injury report — info via ESPN.
None of that guarantees a laugher. Rivalry games have flipped scripts in this series before, and Florida State has the receivers to make Miami's secondary work for every possession. But on paper, this is a program on a national-title arc hosting a rival still trying to find its footing — which is exactly the kind of setup that makes primetime editions of this rivalry appointment viewing.
