Betting HubSharp Action
Barstool BushChronicling the Barstool Universe

Illinois State Redbirds at Northern Illinois Huskies

Sep 12, 20266:00 PM CTDekalb, IL
By JR·2 min read
Illinois State
Northern Illinois
28—24
FINAL

TLDR: Illinois State just played for a national championship. Northern Illinois just lost its head coach to the NFL. This 58th meeting of an in-state series that's dead even isn't the buy game it looks like on paper.

FINAL · SAT SEP 12, 11:00 PM
Illinois State
28
Northern Illinois
24
Final1Q2Q3Q4QT
ILST
1470728
NIU
0170724
76°
Illinois State Redbirds
  • FCS national runner-up, 12-4 with 4 road playoff wins
  • Brock Spack back for 18th season, total continuity
  • 18-3 on the road over the last two seasons
  • Lost QB Tommy Rittenhouse (3,568 yds, 40 TD)
  • Open competition between a redshirt freshman and a transfer
  • Still facing the base talent/depth gap of an FBS road trip
Northern Illinois Huskies
  • Home opener at Huskie Stadium, FBS roster depth
  • Program has a recent history of marquee upsets (Notre Dame)
  • Went 3-9 in 2025 with no bowl appearance
  • Lost head coach Thomas Hammock to the NFL in February
  • Four-way open QB competition with no starter set

Start with the quarterback picture, because neither side has a settled one. NIU's spring showcase turned into an open four-man scramble — redshirt seniors Jalen Macon and Ean Hamric, sophomore Brady Davidson and freshman Bryshawn Brown all got runs with the first team — and nobody locked down the job. Illinois State has its own vacancy after Tommy Rittenhouse, who threw for 3,568 yards and 40 touchdowns in 2025, ran out of eligibility. Redshirt freshman Beckham Pellant and USC transfer Gage Roy are fighting it out to replace him.

The bigger story in DeKalb is on the sideline. Thomas Hammock — the coach who delivered NIU's signature win over Notre Dame and steadied the program for seven years — bolted in February to coach running backs for the Seattle Seahawks. Defensive coordinator Rob Harley is running the show as interim head coach for a team that just went 3-9, and NIU is simultaneously making its first trip through a new conference, the Mountain West, after years in the MAC. That's a lot of change to absorb before Week 1 even snaps.

Illinois State, by contrast, is the picture of continuity. Brock Spack is back for his 18th season after directing arguably the best year in program history — an 8-3 regular season, a run to the FCS national title game, and four straight road playoff wins over ranked opposition, including a stunner over No. 1 North Dakota State. The Redbirds finished 12-4 and lost the championship to Montana State in overtime. Markets haven't posted numbers on this one yet, but a program coming off that kind of run doesn't show up to a rebuilding host as a pushover.

History backs that up. This series sits at 24-24-9 all-time, and Illinois State has gone 18-3 on the road over the last two seasons, including wins over FBS Colorado State and Northwestern in years past. NIU still has the roster depth that comes with being the FBS side, and home openers at Huskie Stadium have swung the program's way before. But an interim staff trying to win its first game with an unsettled quarterback room is a different animal than the Hammock-era Huskies that made their name upsetting ranked opponents.

Whichever quarterback question gets answered first could decide this one. If NIU's staff settles on a starter in fall camp and gets a clean read on the interim-coach bump that sometimes juices a program in year one, this looks like a normal, if shaky, home win. If Illinois State's newcomer at quarterback plays anything like Rittenhouse did behind that veteran-heavy roster, the Redbirds have the pedigree and the road résumé to walk into DeKalb and make it 25 wins in the series.

Illinois State 28, Northern Illinois 24: Final Score & Odds Recap — FCS Darlings Crash Huskies' Coaching Chaos in DeKalb