Michigan Wolverines at Rutgers Scarlet Knights

Oct 31, 202611:30 AM CTBTNPiscataway, NJ
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Michigan just lost a 13-6 game in overtime and couldn't find a touchdown in regulation. Its next stop is Piscataway, where Rutgers has given up 40-plus points 3 times in its last 5 games, so something has to give.

SAT 10/31, 11:30 AM CT · Week 9BTN
Kickoff 55°

Michigan (4-3) visits Rutgers (2-5) with 2 teams trending in opposite directions on each side of the ball: the Wolverines have an elite defense attached to an offense that scored 6 in regulation against Indiana, and the Scarlet Knights can score but just allowed 42 at Northwestern. Both teams have quarterback questions after Michigan's Carr/Underwood split and Lonergan's head injury. Whether Michigan's offense can exploit a depleted Rutgers secondary likely decides it.

Michigan Wolverines
  • Held No. 6 Indiana to 80 passing yards
  • Defense facing a Rutgers QB room in flux
  • Rutgers secondary just lost CB Sanders for season
  • 6 regulation points vs Indiana, no touchdowns
  • 28 first-half rushing yards, line missing Sprague
  • Carr/Underwood split leaves QB role unsettled
Rutgers Scarlet Knights
  • Scored 35 vs USC and 37 at Maryland
  • Home at SHI against a sputtering offense
  • Lonergan left Northwestern game with head injury
  • Allowed 42 or more in 3 of last 5
  • Down 21-3 after 1 quarter at Northwestern

Halloween football in Piscataway starts with the quarterback picture, and both teams have a problem there. Tommy Carr made his first start for Michigan against Indiana, with Bryce Underwood coming in during the second quarter. The two of them didn't produce much. Carr finished 20-for-32 for 167 yards, threw an interception and lost a fumble in the first half, and Michigan ran for just 28 yards before the break. On the other side, Rutgers lost Dylan Lonergan to a blow to the head 6 minutes into the first quarter at Northwestern, and Greg Schiano ruled him out at halftime. Neither team can say yet who will be under center on Saturday, October 31.

Michigan's defense is the most reliable unit in this game. It held a No. 6 Indiana team to 80 passing yards, Zeke Berry picked off a pass, and the Wolverines still lost because the offense managed only 2 field goals. Trey Butkowski's 26-yarder as time expired forced overtime, and Indiana ended it with a 4-yard Josh Hoover touchdown run. Michigan has scored 14, 21 and 6 in its last 3 Big Ten games. Even with that defense, the Wolverines are 1-3 in conference play.

Rutgers' trouble is on the other side of the ball. Northwestern led 21-3 after 1 quarter. Aidan Chiles went 19-for-25 for 219 yards and 3 touchdowns and ran for 83 more, and Caleb Komolafe added 150 rushing yards. The Scarlet Knights can score when things are working: they put up 35 on USC and 37 in a win at Maryland. The defense just keeps giving up big numbers.

10/24Lvs4Indiana6-13
10/17WvsPenn State21-18
10/03L@Minnesota14-20
09/26LvsIowa19-20
09/19WvsUTEP52-17
10/24L@20Northwestern14-42
10/17W@Maryland37-30
10/04Lvs4Indiana15-47
09/25WvsHoward58-7
09/19LvsUSC35-42

The form card shows how similar these two teams are right now. Both are 2-3 over their last 5, and both are 1-3 in the Big Ten. Michigan's wins are a 52-17 rout of UTEP and a 21-18 grinder over Penn State. Its losses to Iowa, Minnesota and Indiana came by 1, 6 and 7 points. Michigan is losing close, low-scoring games, while Rutgers is losing by 4 touchdowns. Those are very different problems.

Rutgers' injury report is thin where it can least afford it. Cornerback K. Sanders has been shut down for the season, which leaves a secondary that just let Chiles complete 76% of his throws with one fewer starter. Receiver F. Toure is still questionable with a knee injury, and the quarterback status is the biggest unknown on the board. For Michigan, guard A. Sprague is still listed out. That matters for an offensive line that couldn't open lanes against Indiana.

It looks like a game Michigan should control on paper, but this Michigan team hasn't controlled much of anything in October. If the Wolverines can't run on a Rutgers defense that just gave up 150 yards to one back, the question shifts from who's playing quarterback to what the offense is actually built to do. The forecast is cloudy and 57 with light wind, so the weather won't be an excuse for anyone.

Michigan vs. Rutgers: Polymarket Odds & Prediction (Oct. 31) — Michigan Brings Its Stalled Offense to Rutgers' Leaky Defense