Oklahoma State Cowboys at Arizona State Sun Devils

Nov 21, 20269:15 PM CTESPNTempe, AZ
By JR·3 min read

TLDR: Oklahoma State scores like it's allergic to punting, and Arizona State wins by refusing to let games get loose. One of those styles takes over in Tempe on Saturday, November 21.

SAT 11/21, 9:15 PM CT · Week 12ESPN
Kickoff 54°

Two 6-4, 4-3 Big 12 teams meet in Tempe with opposite identities: Oklahoma State's high-scoring, leaky offense-first team against Arizona State's run-heavy, low-scoring team built around freshmen Jake Fette and Cardae Mack. Mestemaker is a game-time decision with a right shoulder stinger, and the Cowboys are also without Desmond Magiya up front and Landon Dean on the defensive line, while Arizona State is missing receiver Omarion Miller. The board opened with Oklahoma State as a narrow road favorite and has tightened since as the quarterback question lingered.

Oklahoma State Cowboys
  • Has scored 49+ in 3 of last 5
  • Scored on 4 of 5 second-half drives vs Tech
  • Big 12 title hopes gone; nothing to save energy for
  • Mestemaker a game-time decision with shoulder stinger
  • OL Magiya out after line lost to Tech's pressure
  • Defense allowed 51 and 52, now without DT Dean
Arizona State Sun Devils
  • Allowed 17 or fewer in 3 of last 4
  • Mack: 111 yards on 25 carries at UCF
  • First winning streak of the season, bowl eligible
  • Hasn't topped 28 points in last 5
  • Freshman QB Fette threw for just 196 at UCF
  • WR Omarion Miller ruled out

Start with the quarterbacks, because both come into game day with a question attached. Drew Mestemaker took a right shoulder stinger when Texas Tech's T.J. Holmes sacked him in the first quarter of the 52-27 loss, and he spent the rest of the night running from Red Raider edge rushers. Per SI's postgame takeaways, he got some of his arm strength back as the game went on. He's still listed questionable, and Oklahoma State is calling him a game-time decision. On the other side, Arizona State is riding true freshman Jake Fette, who went 21-of-36 for 196 yards in the win at UCF. That's not a big line. It was enough because the Sun Devils didn't need him to do much more.

The Texas Tech loss ended Oklahoma State's faint Big 12 title hopes, and the way it happened matters for Tempe. Tech returned the opening kickoff 97 yards and led 21-0 before the Cowboys got on the board. Then the Cowboys came back, scoring on 4 of 5 second-half possessions, before stalling in the third quarter on failed short-yardage tries and 4th downs. Tech shut down the outside zone run game and won the line of scrimmage, and Eric Morris has to fix that front without offensive lineman Desmond Magiya, who is out. That's a tough job against a defense that has held 3 of its last 4 opponents to 17 or fewer. The board is up now with the Cowboys as a narrow road favorite, and their price has drifted noticeably toward Arizona State since it opened as Mestemaker's status stayed unresolved.

Arizona State's week was strange. A nationwide FAA ground stop delayed the trip to Orlando by 17 hours, and the Sun Devils landed less than 4 hours before kickoff. They beat UCF 26-13 anyway, clinching bowl eligibility and winning their first true road game of the season. It was also their first back-to-back wins of the year. Freshman running back Cardae Mack carried 25 times for 111 yards and a touchdown, which is the formula: lean on the run, shorten the game and dare the opponent to string together long drives. That formula matters even more now, because wide receiver Omarion Miller has been ruled out, which takes a target away from a freshman quarterback who already wasn't throwing much.

11/15Lvs12Texas Tech27-52
11/07W@Kansas State66-28
10/31L@Iowa State49-51
10/24WvsColorado57-24
10/17L@20Houston32-35
11/14W@UCF26-13
11/08WvsColorado20-10
10/31L@10BYU20-27
10/24WvsKansas State28-17
10/17L@12Texas Tech25-53

The two résumés barely look like the same sport. Oklahoma State has put up 66 at Kansas State and 57 on Colorado in its last 5, and it also lost a 51-49 shootout at Iowa State and gave up 52 to Tech. Arizona State hasn't topped 28 in that stretch and hasn't needed to. Since the 53-25 beating at Texas Tech, the Sun Devils have allowed 17, 27, 10 and 13. Both teams beat Kansas State and Colorado, and both got run over by the Red Raiders, so the common opponents settle nothing.

So it comes down to tempo, and to who takes the first snap for Oklahoma State. The Cowboys' injury list goes well past the quarterback: receiver Dayvon Standard, tight end Carson Kolb, defensive tackle Landon Dean and linebacker Tate Romney are all out, and tight end Morgan McPhaul is questionable. If Mestemaker plays and the patched-up line holds up better than it did against Tech, Oklahoma State can turn this into the kind of game Arizona State has avoided for a month. If the Sun Devils get Mack going against a defensive front missing Dean and keep the Cowboys' offense on the sideline, a 6-4 team with nothing left to play for in the Big 12 has to win a slow game on the road at night in Tempe. Expect 55 degrees, clouds and almost no wind, so the weather won't decide anything.

Free Picks
Oklahoma State vs. Arizona State: Polymarket Odds & Prediction (Nov. 21) — Oklahoma State's Track Meet Offense Runs Into Arizona State's Grind