South Dakota Coyotes at Boise State Broncos

Sat Sep 19 · 9:00 PM CT
By Pablo SanchezUpdated 7d ago·2 min read
South Dakota CoyotesSDAK
Boise State BroncosBOIS
AT
9:00 PM CT

Boise State is supposed to be running the table in its first Pac-12 season, but a South Dakota team that's made the FCS quarterfinals three years running shows up on the blue turf sandwiched between two real tests.

Bush’s Picks
SDAKBOIS
SDAKBOIS
OverUnder
Best BetBoise State

Boise State is the far more talented, far more experienced team here, returning its starting quarterback and its top two backs while South Dakota is breaking in a brand-new starter behind a rebuilt offensive line. This is about as clean a moneyline lean as the schedule offers all season for the Broncos.

South Dakota
  • Reached FCS quarterfinals 3 straight seasons
  • Chris Dixon returns after ~70 tackles, 4 TFLs
  • Hit portal hard on both lines and secondary
  • Loses 3.5-year starting QB Aidan Bouman
  • 5 of 6 starting offensive linemen gone
  • First-year head coach, unsettled QB competition
Boise State
  • Madsen returns behind Riley/Gaines, 1,900+ yards combined
  • Enters as Pac-12's clear favorite in year one
  • Deep FBS talent gap against an FCS opponent
  • All 3 leading receivers from 2025 are gone
  • Lost 4 starters out of last year's secondary
  • Sandwiched between road trips to Oregon and Western Michigan

This one's about who's steady at quarterback and who isn't. Maddux Madsen is back for another year running Boise State's offense, and he's got Dylan Riley and Sire Gaines behind him after the pair combined for over 1,900 yards and 18 touchdowns last season. South Dakota is starting over. Aidan Bouman, a 3.5-year starter who owns a chunk of the program's passing records, is gone, and new head coach Matt Vitzthum is still sorting out a QB competition between a system veteran, a young prospect, and a transfer with FCS starting experience.

South Dakota isn't walking in overmatched everywhere. Chris Dixon returns up front after nearly 70 tackles and 4 tackles for loss a year ago, and the Coyotes hit the transfer portal hard on both lines and in the secondary to patch holes. But an offense that also lost its top running back, its top two receivers, and five of six starting offensive linemen from a 10-5 quarterfinal team is a lot to replace in one offseason, and it's fair to wonder how much of that identity survives the opener against a Pac-12 favorite.

Show fees
9:00 PM CT
Spread
ML
Total
SDAK South Dakota
BOIS Boise State

Boise State has its own questions, just further down the depth chart. All three leading receivers from last season are gone — Latrell Caples and Chase Penry used up their eligibility, and Chris Marshall transferred to Arkansas — so someone new has to emerge opposite Madsen. The Broncos also lost four starters out of last year's secondary. None of that changes the math against South Dakota specifically, but it's the backdrop for a Broncos team trying to find its identity three games into a season that started at Oregon and continues on the road at Western Michigan the following week.

This is also just the second all-time meeting between these programs, and the first at the FBS level for both. South Dakota's built its recent identity on physicality and defense, reaching the FCS quarterterfinals — er, quarterfinals — in three straight seasons under the previous staff. That pedigree buys the Coyotes some respect, but reputation doesn't fill five new starting spots on the offensive line.

South Dakota Coyotes
South Dakota Coyotes
Boise State Broncos
Boise State Broncos
Sep 12?vs Memphis
Sep 5?@ Oregon
Recent form.

Where this could get interesting is if South Dakota's new QB settles in fast and the Coyotes' portal pickups on the D-line and in the secondary give Boise some early trouble. Vitzthum inherited a program that knows how to win close games in the FCS ranks, and a defense anchored by Dixon, plus edge rushers Nathan Laperi and Nyle Dickel, isn't just there to make up the numbers.

South Dakota Coyotes
South Dakota Coyotes
(0)
Fully healthy — no injuries on ESPN's report
Boise State Broncos
Boise State Broncos
(0)
Fully healthy — no injuries on ESPN's report
Injury report — info via ESPN.

Boise State's margin for error is basically nonexistent here in terms of public expectation — anything less than a comfortable win raises real questions about the receiver room and the new-look secondary heading into the Western Michigan trip. For South Dakota, this is about establishing what the Vitzthum era looks like against a genuinely good FBS team, not really about the scoreboard.

CFBSouth Dakota CoyotesBoise State BroncosPinnaclePolymarketKalshi