Houston Astros at Philadelphia Phillies

Thu Sep 101:05 PM ETPhiladelphia, PA
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Zack Wheeler was nearly untouchable and the Phillies still lost — a 9th-inning gut punch capped a series split that decided almost nothing except who's angrier about it.

FINAL · THU SEP 10, 5:05 PM
LWLLW
2
1
Final123456789RHE
HOU
010000001280
PHI
000010000131
1st pitch 87°

Zack Wheeler was excellent and it still wasn't enough — Houston's bullpen held up, Philadelphia's offense went cold, and the Astros stole a 2-1 finale on a 9th-inning run. Both clubs left Citizens Bank Park with their season-long pictures unchanged: Houston clinging to the AL West, Philadelphia still four games back and fighting for a wild card.

Houston Astros
  • Rotation ERA near 2.56 over last 11 games
  • Leads AL West despite uneven run differential
  • Javier hasn't worked past 5 innings since return
  • Bullpen down Okert, Burrows, Walter to injury
Philadelphia Phillies
  • Wheeler dominant since fixing glove-position flaw
  • Won last meeting 11-7, wild-card chase alive
  • Four relievers out: Banks, Kilian, Keller, Reyes
  • Four games back in NL East race

The pitching matchup Thursday was a mismatch on paper that turned into anything but. Wheeler (12-5, 3.16 ERA) took the ball fresh off a 9-strikeout gem against Atlanta, while Cristian Javier — working back from a rocky season — brought a bloated 5.56 ERA into Citizens Bank Park off a surprising 8-K outing of his own against Arizona.

Cristian Javier
Cristian Javier
(2-6)·5.14 ERA
Sep 4 vs Diamondbacks
W
5.0IP
1ER
8K
3BB
79P
09/10 Lineup
Zack Wheeler
Zack Wheeler
(13-5)·3.06 ERA
Sep 5 vs Braves
W
6.0IP
1ER
9K
2BB
95P
09/10 Lineup

Houston's bullpen has been running thin, down Steven Okert, Mike Burrows and Brandon Walter to injury, which made a low-scoring grind exactly the kind of game that could've gone either way in relief. Philadelphia's relief corps isn't exactly full-strength either, missing Tanner Banks, Caleb Kilian, Brad Keller and Felix Reyes, and that mutual bullpen fatigue loomed over a 1:05 PM ET first pitch under mostly sunny skies and 89-degree heat.

Both offenses had scuffled through the first two games of this set before Thursday, and the finale played out like a rubber match between two flawed rosters — Houston clinging to the AL West lead despite an uneven run differential, Philadelphia four games back in the NL East and still scrapping in the wild-card race.

Wheeler was every bit the ace the Phillies needed, but Javier matched him for most of the afternoon, and it came down to which bullpen cracked first. Houston's did not.

Philadelphia scratched across a run in the 5th to tie it, and for a while it looked like Wheeler's line would be the story of the day. Instead, Houston's offense — which had piled up 8 hits on the day compared to Philadelphia's 3 — found one more run in the 9th to steal it, with an error charged to the Phillies defense not helping matters.

09/09L@Phillies7-11
09/08W@Phillies6-5
09/06LvsDiamondbacks2-3
09/05LvsDiamondbacks3-4
09/04WvsDiamondbacks3-1
09/09WvsAstros11-7
09/08LvsAstros5-6
09/07WvsBraves1-0
09/06LvsBraves4-5
09/05WvsBraves4-2

It was the kind of game that swung on a handful of at-bats rather than any structural advantage, and it left both clubs exactly where they were before it started: Houston still hanging onto first, Philadelphia still chasing.

Astros 2, Phillies 1: Final Score & Odds Recap — Wheeler Deals, Astros Steal One Late in Philly