Toronto Blue Jays at Athletics

Mon Sep 77:05 PM PT
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Toronto's ace rolls into Sacramento carrying one of the best ERAs in baseball, and the team on the other side of the diamond is playing out a lost season in a temporary ballpark.

FINAL · TUE SEP 8, 2:05 AM
5
6
Final123456789RHE
TOR
010000301593
ATH
202010001660
Toronto Blue Jays
  • Dylan Cease has a 2.25 ERA, Cy Young-caliber season
  • have won 4 of last 5 as of Sunday
  • already 3-0 against Oakland this season
  • rotation stripped to essentially just Cease behind 3 IL arms
  • lost their last time out to Kansas City
  • 72-72, largely playing out the string
Athletics
  • have also won 4 of last 5 as of Sunday
  • took 3 of the first 4 from Seattle
  • Lopez building back into form after a lost 2025
  • 57-87, well into a rebuild
  • missing Rooker, Kurtz, Soderstrom and Wilson for the season
  • Lopez's ERA sits at 4.71

First pitch at Sutter Health Park is set for 7:05 PM PT, with Dylan Cease starting for the Blue Jays and Jacob Lopez taking the ball for the Athletics. Cease has been the best story in Toronto's rotation all year, and he's coming off a start against Cleveland where he went 6 innings, allowed 0 earned runs, struck out 4 and needed only 83 pitches to get through it.

Dylan Cease
Dylan Cease
(11-6)·2.40 ERA
Sep 2 @ Guardians
W
6.0IP
0ER
4K
0BB
83P
09/07 Lineup
Jacob Lopez
Jacob Lopez
(6-5)·5.68 ERA
Sep 2 @ Rangers
W
6.0IP
2ER
7K
2BB
102P
09/07 Lineup

Lopez's road back has been longer. He lost the back half of his 2025 season to a flexor strain in his throwing elbow, and this year has largely been about rebuilding a workload — his last time out against Texas, he went 6 innings, allowed 2 earned runs and struck out 7 in a winning effort. The Blue Jays, meanwhile, are without 3 rotation arms behind Cease: Shane Bieber, Jameson Taillon and Trey Yesavage are all on the injured list, which has left Toronto leaning hard on its ace every time he takes the ball, and the DraftKings board reflects exactly that imbalance.

None of that rotation math changes tonight, since Cease is walking into a lineup missing Brent Rooker, Nick Kurtz, Tyler Soderstrom and Jacob Wilson for the season, plus Shea Langeliers still working back from a knee injury. The Polymarket room for this one was quiet next to the rest of the season's rooms, sitting at roughly 5% of a typical night's turnout, and the sliver of pregame chatter that did show up leaned toward the home side.

Toronto sits at 72-72, deep enough into September that this is closer to evaluation baseball than a pennant chase, while the Athletics are 57-87 and further along in a rebuild now playing out in a minor-league ballpark while the franchise waits on its permanent Las Vegas home. This is the 4th meeting between these two clubs this season, and Toronto has taken all 3 of the first 3, covering the run line in 2 of them — a trend that's held regardless of who's started for the Blue Jays.

09/06L@Royals1-6
09/05W@Royals4-3
09/04W@Royals9-2
09/03W@Guardians6-3
09/02W@Guardians11-0
(57-87)
09/06L@Mariners0-2
09/05W@Mariners6-2
09/04W@Mariners7-6
09/03W@Mariners7-4
09/02W@Rangers9-2

A clean final month from Cease only strengthens his case for the American League Cy Young, and a dominant start against an offense this shorthanded would be about as good a showcase as he could ask for. For the Athletics, it's a matter of getting through the next month healthy and finding out which of their young arms and bats belong in the 2027 mix.

Blue Jays 5, Athletics 6: Final Score & Odds Recap — Cease Brings Cy Young Form Into Sacramento Against The A's