Toronto Blue Jays at Athletics

Wed Sep 912:05 PM PTWest Sacramento, CA
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: A Blue Jays club chasing a wild-card spot walked into Sacramento and got shut out by one of the worst teams in baseball.

FINAL · WED SEP 9, 7:05 PM
0
2
Final123456789RHE
TOR
000000000060
ATH
00110000—240
1st pitch 92°

The Athletics blanked Toronto 2-0 at Sutter Health Park, riding two middle-inning runs and a bounce-back start from Brady Basso to beat a Blue Jays club that had won its last game before this one. Toronto managed 6 hits but couldn't convert any of them, leaving a playoff-chasing offense searching for answers against a last-place opponent already missing four everyday regulars for the season.

Toronto Blue Jays
  • Playoff push, in the thick of the wild-card race
  • Answered Monday's loss with a win the very next night
  • Five starting pitchers already lost to the IL
  • Leaning on a bulk/opener role on the road
Athletics
  • Won the series opener on a walk-off
  • Held their own, split the first two games
  • Five core regulars out for the rest of the year
  • Rookie starter got roughed up his last time out

Braydon Fisher (3-4, 3.15 ERA) worked in a bulk/opener role for Toronto, with Brady Basso (1-2, 3.96 ERA) starting for the Athletics as first pitch went off at 12:05 PM PT at Sutter Health Park in Sacramento.

Braydon Fisher
Braydon Fisher
(3-4)·3.25 ERA
Aug 15 vs Yankees
ND
1.0IP
0ER
0K
1BB
12P
09/09 Lineup
Brady Basso
Brady Basso
(1-3)·5.36 ERA
Sep 1 @ Rangers
L
2.1IP
2ER
2K
0BB
40P
09/09 Lineup

Toronto came in without George Springer, held out of the lineup as day-to-day, and Anthony Santander has been working back from a shoulder injury on a rehab assignment rather than helping this offense. The Athletics, meanwhile, are already down four everyday regulars for the rest of the season — Jacob Wilson, Nick Kurtz, Brent Rooker and Tyler Soderstrom are all done — which is the kind of roster gap that had shaded the market toward Toronto before first pitch.

Both clubs came in having split the first two games of this set, with the Athletics having taken the opener on a walk-off, so nothing about the price reflected a lopsided series to that point.

Toronto's rotation has been gutted all year — Bieber, Taillon, Yesavage, Corbin and Berrios have all spent time on the injured list — which is why a reliever like Fisher was opening games in September for a team still fighting for October.

09/08W@Athletics4-2
09/07L@Athletics5-6
09/06L@Royals1-6
09/05W@Royals4-3
09/04W@Royals9-2
(58-88)
09/08LvsBlue Jays2-4
09/07WvsBlue Jays6-5
09/06L@Mariners0-2
09/05W@Mariners6-2
09/04W@Mariners7-6

That split series backdrop meant this finale carried real stakes for a Toronto club trying to close out the head-to-head set on a positive note.

None of that mattered once the game started. The Athletics scratched across single runs in back-to-back innings and made it stand, needing only 4 hits while a Toronto lineup that had won its last game before this one managed 6 hits and nothing to show for them.

The Polymarket chat room ran well above its usual crowd for an Athletics game, and by the finish one poster summed up the mood simply: 'Thanks for the easy money kids.' It was Basso, not Fisher, who came out the better arm, and the Athletics moved ahead in this set instead of the wild-card hopeful that walked in as the favorite.

Blue Jays 0, Athletics 2: Final Score & Odds Recap — Athletics Blank Toronto 2-0 As Blue Jays' Bats Go Silent