Toronto Blue Jays at Cleveland Guardians

Tue Sep 16:40 PM ET
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Cleveland turned a scoreless game into a laugher over the final four innings, and Toronto is running out of answers for a lineup that just got shut down at Progressive Field.

FINAL · TUE SEP 1, 10:40 PM
1
6
Final123456789RHE
TOR
000010000130
CLE
00002022—681
Toronto Blue Jays
  • Swept Seattle 3-0 right before this series
  • Spencer Miles carries a 2.88 ERA, 5-2 record
  • Rotation gutted: Yesavage, Taillon, Bieber, Bloss, Corbin, Berrios, Ponce, Francis all hurt
  • Dropped the series opener to Cleveland, 1-6
Cleveland Guardians
  • Won 2 straight, capped by a 6-1 rout of Toronto
  • Gavin Williams has 13 wins, tops among Cleveland starters
  • Williams was chased after just 1.1 innings in his last start
  • Rhys Hoskins still out with a back injury

Spencer Miles took the ball for Toronto and Gavin Williams for Cleveland, and neither arm walked in radiating total confidence. Miles is working off a short, low-pitch turn against Kansas City, while Williams was chased after just 1.1 innings in his previous start against the Angels. That volatility from both starters made the middle innings the swing point of the whole night.

Spencer Miles
Spencer Miles
(6-2)·2.71 ERA
Aug 26 vs Royals
ND
2.0IP
0ER
1K
0BB
33P
09/01 Lineup
Gavin Williams
Gavin Williams
(13-8)·3.78 ERA
Aug 25 @ Angels
ND
1.1IP
5ER
3K
1BB
62P
09/01 Lineup

Toronto's need for length out of anybody not named a scrap-heap starter isn't going away soon. The Blue Jays are missing basically an entire projected rotation — Trey Yesavage is only just building back up from knee surgery, Jameson Taillon is trying to work back from a forearm issue, and Shane Bieber, Bowden Francis, Jose Berrios and Cody Ponce are all done for extended stretches or the year. Cleveland's injury list is lighter by comparison — Rhys Hoskins is still out with a back issue, and Shawn Armstrong and Slade Cecconi are working back from their own — but nothing close to Toronto's attrition.

Both clubs are jammed into the thick of the American League wild-card picture as September opens, which is exactly why a series opener like this one carries more weight than the final score alone suggests. Every game either team drops now is one it likely has to make up somewhere else down the stretch.

09/01L@Guardians1-6
08/30WvsMariners7-0
08/29WvsMariners4-3
08/28WvsMariners8-1
08/27LvsRoyals2-13
09/01WvsBlue Jays6-1
08/30WvsRoyals11-1
08/29LvsRoyals3-8
08/28LvsRoyals0-3
08/26W@Angels4-3

The line score tells the real story: nothing happened for four innings, then Cleveland broke through in the 5th, added on in the 7th, and piled more on in the 8th, while Toronto's only run of the night also came in the 5th. Eight hits and 6 runs for the Guardians against 3 hits and 1 run for the Blue Jays is exactly as lopsided as a 6-1 final sounds.

For Cleveland, the win stretches a run in which the Guardians have won 2 straight after alternating results against Kansas City — the kind of game a wild-card hopeful needs to bank without much drama. For Toronto, it's the flip side of the same coin: a lineup that had just swept Seattle 3-0 rolled into Cleveland and opened this set with a loss.

None of this fixes Toronto's bigger problem, which is that a lineup capable of sweeping a bad Mariners club still needs pitching it doesn't currently have. Cleveland doesn't need to be spectacular the rest of the way — just competent enough that Hoskins' bat coming back matters more than it hurts right now that it's missing.

Blue Jays 1, Guardians 6: Final Score & Odds Recap — Guardians Bury Blue Jays, 6-1, In Series Opener