San Francisco Giants at Pittsburgh Pirates

Tue Sep 16:40 PM ET
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Neither starter made it out of the fifth, both bullpens got torched, and Pittsburgh was the last team standing in a 13-12 slugfest at PNC Park.

FINAL · TUE SEP 1, 10:40 PM
WWLLW
12
WWLLW
13
Final123456789RHE
SF
05000205012161
PIT
20900010113190
San Francisco Giants
  • Devers provided the game's biggest hit, a 3-run homer
  • Won 2 straight and beat Atlanta before this game
  • Cruz's counterpart bats aside, lineup had pop all night
  • Rotation down 3 starters to season-ending injuries
  • Webb got knocked out in the second inning
  • Bullpen missing multiple relievers to injury
Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Skenes still one of the game's top arms overall
  • Won 2 straight, taken 2 of first 3 from St. Louis
  • Cruz and Lowe delivered when the pen faltered
  • Skenes got tagged for 5 earned in a shaky outing
  • Bullpen let a big lead nearly slip away in the eighth
  • Down starter Mitch Keller and now catcher Endy Rodriguez

Logan Webb and Paul Skenes were both good enough to be handed the ball Tuesday, and neither one made it out alive. Webb lasted 2.0 innings before Pittsburgh strung together 9 runs in the third, and Skenes followed him to the showers in the fifth after San Francisco answered with a 5-run second built around a Rafael Devers homer. First pitch at PNC Park came at 6:40 PM ET, and by the time both aces were gone the game had barely started.

Logan Webb
Logan Webb
(8-9)·4.31 ERA
Aug 26 vs Reds
ND
6.0IP
2ER
6K
1BB
97P
09/01 Lineup
Paul Skenes
Paul Skenes
(10-11)·3.78 ERA
Aug 25 @ Padres
ND
6.0IP
0ER
4K
0BB
87P
09/01 Lineup

What was left was a bullpen game neither pen was built to win clean. The Giants are already threadbare in relief — Sam Hentges (forearm), Matt Gage (elbow) and Joel Peguero (hamstring, season-ending) are all out — and it showed when San Francisco needed length it didn't have. Pittsburgh's pen wasn't spotless either, coughing up 5 more in the eighth before the Pirates survived it, a group that's already working without Mitch Keller (arm) and now without catcher Endy Rodriguez, who landed on the 60-day IL Tuesday.

Oneil Cruz kept hammering singles into the mess for 3 RBI, and Brandon Lowe answered a late Giants push with a home run in the seventh. San Francisco clawed back with 5 more in the eighth to make it a game again, but Pittsburgh pushed across the winning run in the ninth on a throwing error and held on, 13-12.

It's the kind of night that erases whatever the box score usually promises about a Cy Young-caliber arm and a well above-average one. Skenes came in off a scoreless 6-inning outing against San Diego and still got hit around for 5 earned on the day; Webb came in with a clean prior start against Cincinnati and got run out of the building before he'd faced 10 batters. Individual form only tells you so much once an inning like that third one starts snowballing.

08/31W@Braves7-3
08/29WvsDiamondbacks7-2
08/29LvsDiamondbacks1-7
08/28LvsDiamondbacks6-10
08/27WvsDiamondbacks6-1
08/30W@Cardinals5-4
08/29W@Cardinals6-2
08/28L@Cardinals1-4
08/26L@Padres0-3
08/25W@Padres1-0

Both clubs are well outside the playoff picture — Pittsburgh at 67-71, San Francisco at 57-81 — which is part of why a game this chaotic still has the feel of two teams playing out the string rather than fighting for anything. The injury lists on both sides only reinforce it: San Francisco is picking through a rotation and bullpen gutted by season-ending moves, and Pittsburgh is monitoring its own list of arms and now a catcher spot as September rolls on.

Giants 12, Pirates 13: Final Score & Odds Recap — Pirates Outlast Giants In 13-12 Wild One At PNC Park