Cleveland Guardians at Tampa Bay Rays

By JR·2 min read
Guardians(85-77)
Rays(98-64)
Tuesday 10/138:00 PM

TLDR: Tampa Bay won 98 games and swept the Yankees, then got outhit 14-7 at home in the ALCS opener. Game 2 at the Trop is the Rays' chance to show that 7-3 loss was a one-off before the series heads to Cleveland.

WED 10/14, 8:00 PMTBStruTV
(98-64)
LWWW

The Cleveland Guardians lead the ALCS 1-0 after a 7-3 Game 1 win at Tropicana Field, where they came back from 2 runs down by scoring 7 straight off the Tampa Bay bullpen. Game 2 turns on whether the Rays' relief corps, hit for 5 runs by Tyler Wells and Cole Sulser in the opener and without Shane McClanahan for the rest of October, can protect a lead for a 98-win team that swept the Yankees on pitching. Cleveland arrives on a 4-game winning streak with a thinned bullpen of its own.

Cleveland Guardians
  • Up 1-0 after outhitting Tampa Bay 14-7
  • Scored 7 unanswered runs late in Game 1
  • Added Cecconi to the ALCS pitching staff
  • Bullpen without Holderman and Walters
  • Hoskins still sidelined with back injury
  • 85-77 club facing a 98-win opponent
Tampa Bay Rays
  • Allowed 5 runs total sweeping the Yankees
  • Rasmussen gave 6 strong innings in Game 1
  • Wells and Sulser tagged for 5 runs in Game 1
  • McClanahan ruled out for the postseason
  • Scored once after the 1st inning in Game 1

The Game 1 starters did their part, and the gap opened after that. Drew Rasmussen got through 6 innings with 2 runs on 8 hits, 7 strikeouts and no walks, and that was the kind of outing Tampa Bay counted on all year. Kevin Cash sent him back out for the 7th, Patrick Bailey led off with a homer to tie it, and Rasmussen left after 91 pitches. Game 2 asks the same question again: can the starter hand the Rays a lead their bullpen can actually keep?

Parker Messick
Parker Messick
(12-9)·2.56 ERA
Sep 27 @ Royals
ND
3.0IP
1ER
2K
1BB
64P
10/13 Lineup
Freddy Peralta
Freddy Peralta
(10-11)·4.42 ERA
Sep 25 @ Phillies
W
5.1IP
0ER
4K
3BB
93P
10/13 Lineup

That bullpen is the story coming into tonight. Cash used 5 relievers in Game 1. Tyler Wells took the loss after giving up 2 earned runs on 6 pitches, and Cole Sulser was charged with 3 more in the 9th. Shane McClanahan is officially done for the postseason with the forearm issue, so the Rays won't get a lefty back to help the staff. Cleveland's staff isn't whole either. Colin Holderman needs season-ending wrist surgery and Andrew Walters had UCL repair, but the Guardians still swapped Cecconi in for Schneemann to fill out the ALCS staff.

Then there's the rust question. The Rays had almost a week off after finishing off the Yankees and scored once after the 1st inning in Game 1. That's the same offense that won its Division Series games 1-0, 5-2 and 4-3, so it has never needed a lot of runs. It needed its pitchers to hold those leads, and in Game 1 the late innings went the other way.

Cleveland is playing about as well as it has all year. The Guardians have won 4 straight, and they finished the regular season by taking 3 of 4 from the White Sox, including a 2-0 shutout. Then they fell behind 2-0 in an opener on the road and scored 7 straight runs. Chase DeLauter and Bailey went deep, and Nathaniel Lowe's 2-run single in the 8th broke the tie. For an 85-77 team, a 14-hit night against a 98-win club's pitching staff says plenty.

10/12W@Rays7-3
10/10WvsWhite Sox2-0
10/08W@White Sox9-5
10/07W@White Sox9-3
10/05LvsWhite Sox3-4
10/12LvsGuardians3-7
10/07W@Yankees4-3
10/05WvsYankees5-2
10/03WvsYankees1-0

Both lineups are missing pieces. Rhys Hoskins is still on the IL for Cleveland, with his back only far enough along for a swing progression. Tampa Bay has Jacob Melton and Gavin Lux on the 60-day list, and Edwin Uceta and Jonathan Heasley are out of the bullpen picture. The Rays' depth won them the division, and this series is now testing it.

First pitch is 8:00 PM ET under the dome in St. Petersburg. Going down 2-0 at home would put the Rays in a real hole heading to Cleveland, and the Guardians already have the split they came for. Tampa Bay's whole season was built on run prevention, and Game 2 is about whether that shows up again from the 7th inning on.

ALCS Game 2: Rays Look to Steady Up After Guardians Steal ALCS Game 1 | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush