New York Mets at Miami Marlins

Tue Sep 86:40 PM ET
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Miami came all the way back from a five-run hole to make it interesting in the ninth, but it wasn't enough — the Mets held on at loanDepot park.

FINAL · TUE SEP 8, 10:40 PM
WWLWW
7
LWLLL
5
Final123456789RHE
NYM
231010000782
MIA
0000040015100
New York Mets
  • 4-1 in last 5, won 2 straight
  • Already beat Miami in the series opener
  • Manaea has allowed 4+ ER in 4 straight starts
  • Bullpen down four relievers to injury
Miami Marlins
  • Still alive in the NL wild-card race
  • Alcantara owns a strong 13-9, 3.54 ERA season
  • Lost 4 of last 5, including to these same Mets
  • Bullpen posting a 5.03 ERA since late June, among MLB's worst

This one had stakes on only one side of the diamond. The Mets are playing out the string at 66-78, mathematically buried in the Wild Card race, while the Marlins are still clinging to the fringes of it at 72-73 — the kind of gap that made this Tuesday feel a lot bigger for the home dugout. Sean Manaea and Sandy Alcantara squared off at 6:40 PM ET with very different seasons riding on the results.

Sean Manaea
Sean Manaea
(5-7)·4.74 ERA
Sep 1 @ Rays
L
5.2IP
5ER
2K
1BB
86P
09/08 Lineup
Sandy Alcantara
Sandy Alcantara
(13-11)·3.91 ERA
Sep 3 @ Royals
L
6.0IP
4ER
2K
1BB
98P
09/08 Lineup

Manaea took the ball on the wrong side of a brutal stretch — he's allowed four or more earned runs in four straight starts and was pulled after just 5.2 innings against Tampa Bay in his last time out. Alcantara, by contrast, has been the best version of himself much of the year, leading the league in innings, even if he'd been touched up for eight runs across his previous two starts. Neither arm was working with much margin for error walking in.

The Polymarket room noticed the Marlins were live — nearly 12,000 members packed the chat, about 58% above the season median, and it stayed buzzing all night as loanDepot Park tried to manufacture a comeback out of thin air.

Miami's bullpen has been getting hit from multiple directions — Pete Fairbanks was working his way back from a hand issue, Anthony Nardi is done for the year, and Anthony Bender was just shut down again — while a laboring Alcantara had to try to hold a laugher together long enough for the pen to survive it.

The Mets jumped out early and often, scoring in three of the first five innings, and by the time the dust settled they'd built a lead that looked comfortable. Miami answered with a four-run sixth to make a real game of it, and the room's busiest stretch of the whole night came right as the Marlins tried to complete the rally in the ninth — one poster holding Miami wrote "And the comeback starts now," while another holding New York countered by thanking "all you Marlins fans who put money down to fund this win."

09/07W@Marlins9-4
09/06WvsGiants4-2
09/05LvsGiants5-9
09/04WvsGiants10-6
09/02W@Rays10-4
09/07LvsMets4-9
09/06WvsCubs10-3
09/05LvsCubs5-6
09/04LvsCubs1-6
09/03L@Royals3-7

It's a strange juxtaposition for a September series — a last-place club playing spoiler against a team still theoretically alive — but for one night, the Mets made sure the fringe contender left the ballpark a little further from where it needs to be.

Mets 7, Marlins 5: Final Score & Odds Recap — Mets Hang On Late, Spoil Marlins' Wild Card Push