New York Mets at Philadelphia Phillies

Thu Jul 166:10 PM ET
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Philadelphia opened the second half as the home favorite with a division chase on the line. Instead, the last-place Mets walked into Citizens Bank Park and beat the Phillies at their own game.

FINAL · THU JUL 16, 10:10 PM
LLLWW
4
1
Final123456789RHE
NYM
001000201471
PHI
000000010141
New York Mets
  • Scott dealing, 2.90 ERA into this start
  • won behind a clean finish from the pen
  • 40-57, well out of any contention
  • rotation and pen gutted by injuries (Holmes, Megill, Garrett)
Philadelphia Phillies
  • 54-43, squarely in the NL East chase
  • Nola coming off an 8-K outing last time out
  • bullpen among the worst in baseball this July
  • lost Keller for the year the same day

Christian Scott, who tossed 5 shutout innings past the Royals his last time out, matched up with Aaron Nola, fresh off an 8-strikeout effort against the Tigers, in the Mets' 6:10 PM ET series opener at Citizens Bank Park. On paper it read as a mismatch in Philadelphia's favor. By the ninth inning, it wasn't close to that.

New York Mets
Christian Scott
(3-3)·2.99 ERA
Jul 8 vs Royals
ND
5.0IP
0ER
5K
1BB
90P
07/16 Lineup
Philadelphia Phillies
Aaron Nola
(3-9)·5.61 ERA
Jul 10 @ Tigers
ND
5.0IP
2ER
8K
2BB
84P
07/16 Lineup

The Phillies didn't just drop a game Thursday — they lost their best setup arm for the year. Brad Keller went on the 15-day IL with a torn UCL, the latest blow to a bullpen that's been among the worst in baseball since July began. Nola had shown signs of getting right in his last outing, but Philadelphia's margin for error late in games has shrunk fast, and the number at Citizens Bank Park still opened with the Phillies comfortably favored anyway.

None of that mattered against Scott, who kept the Phillies off the board deep into the game while the Mets chipped away. A run in the 3rd got the scoring started, and New York broke it open late — 2 more in the 7th, another in the 9th — while Philadelphia's lone run didn't come until the 8th. For a Mets team playing out the string at 40-57 under interim manager Andy Green, it was about as clean a night as this roster's had in weeks.

This is the kind of loss that stings more than a typical series opener for Philadelphia. A team trying to chase down a division lead can't afford a bullpen bleeding runs in July, and Keller's injury means the back of games gets even thinner. The offense didn't do Nola or the pen any favors either — just 4 hits and 1 run isn't the formula for erasing a rough stretch.

Green's Mets, by contrast, have nothing to lose and increasingly look like it. Scott has quietly turned into one of the few bright spots in a lost season, and this was the kind of complete effort — length from the starter, a clean finish from the pen — this club hasn't strung together often. It won't move the standings, but nights like this are exactly what an interim staff wants to see from its young arms.

07/12LvsRed Sox2-3
07/11LvsRed Sox0-4
07/10LvsRed Sox2-6
07/09WvsRoyals7-3
07/08WvsRoyals6-2
07/12W@Tigers5-0
07/11W@Tigers4-2
07/10L@Tigers2-10
07/09W@Reds1-0
07/08L@Reds5-11

For Philadelphia, the real worry isn't one bad night — it's whether the bullpen crunch turns into a summer-long problem right when every win matters in a crowded NL East chase. For the Mets, this one's about individual building blocks, not the table. Both storylines carry into the rest of the series.

Mets 4, Phillies 1: Final Score & Odds Recap — Mets Silence Phillies Bats, Bullpen Crisis Grows in Philly · Barstool Bush