New York Mets at New York Yankees

Sun Sep 131:35 PM ETBronx, NY
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: The Yankees closed out the Subway Series the way they opened the weekend hoping to, riding another shutdown start from Cam Schlittler to a 2-0 win at Yankee Stadium.

FINAL · SUN SEP 13, 5:35 PM
LWLWW
0
WLWWW
2
Final123456789RHE
NYM
000000000030
NYY
10100000—230
71°

The Yankees took the Subway Series finale 2-0 behind another dominant Cam Schlittler start, with solo homers from Ben Rice and Austin Wells supplying the only runs against a Christian Scott outing that was better than the pregame form suggested. New York wins the finale and the series 2-1, still chasing Tampa Bay in the AL East; the Mets close the book on this year's crosstown series having been outscored on balance but with a legitimate answer in Scott's final line.

New York Mets
  • Scott struck out 7 with just 2 walks over a full start
  • Held Yankees' lineup to two solo homers, nothing more
  • Matched a Cy Young-caliber arm shot for shot into the 6th
  • Offense managed only 3 hits, shut out on the day
  • Series ends 1-2 after Sunday's finale loss
  • No answer for either Rice or Wells homer
New York Yankees
  • Schlittler one-hit the Mets across 6 scoreless innings
  • Rice's leadoff homer was his 38th of the season
  • Wells snapped an 0-for-20 slump with a 392-foot blast
  • Schlittler struck by a comebacker, forced out after 6
  • Offense scored only 2 runs on 3 total hits
  • Still trail Tampa Bay by 4 games with the finale banked

Schlittler (14-6, 1.95 ERA) took the ball for the rubber game looking to answer Saturday's 12-2 blowout loss, and Christian Scott, still building back up from a hybrid Tommy John procedure, drew the other side. Both arms delivered exactly the kind of start their recent form promised — Schlittler carried his AL-leading ERA into six scoreless innings, and Scott matched him blow for blow into the sixth before two solo shots decided it.

Christian Scott
Christian Scott
(4-5)·3.85 ERA
Sep 6 vs Giants
ND
4.2IP
2ER
7K
0BB
80P
09/13 Lineup
Cam Schlittler
Cam Schlittler
(14-6)·1.95 ERA
Sep 8 vs Rockies
W
7.0IP
1ER
10K
0BB
96P
09/13 Lineup

Scott struck out 7 with 2 walks and allowed only the two home runs and 3 hits total, a step up in workload from the 4.2 innings and 80 pitches he'd managed in his last outing. Schlittler needed 94 pitches to finish his six, whiffing 8 Mets and getting hit by a comebacker off his leg late — Aaron Boone said afterward he took it "pretty good" and should be fine.

Ben Rice opened the scoring with a leadoff-inning solo homer, his 38th of the year, and Austin Wells followed with a 392-foot blast in the third that snapped a 0-for-20 slump. That was it for offense on either side — the Mets' 3 hits matched the Yankees' output, and neither lineup found another gear the rest of the way.

The Polymarket chat ran hot for a Sunday matinee, drawing a crowd 24% above the season's median for an MLB room. "I need our percentage to jump to 80% asap," one poster holding the Mets wrote as the deficit sat at two, while another guessed "it's gonna end 5-3" — a line that aged about as well as most in-game predictions do against a pitcher's duel that finished 2-0.

09/13L@Yankees0-2
09/12W@Yankees12-2
09/11L@Yankees4-6
09/09W@Marlins15-14
09/08W@Marlins7-5
09/13WvsMets2-0
09/12LvsMets2-12
09/11WvsMets6-4
09/10WvsRockies10-3
09/09WvsRockies6-1

Bednar closed it out for his 34th save, and the bullpen behind Schlittler didn't allow a baserunner to matter. New York clinched a playoff berth before this series even started; Sunday's win instead does the more immediate work of keeping pace in a division race the Yankees still trail by 4 games.

For the Mets, it's a tidier ending than Saturday's laugher suggested was coming — Scott's final line is the best evidence yet that his innings limit is loosening up, even in a loss. New York finishes this year's Subway Series having taken one of three, a fair reflection of two clubs playing very different games down the stretch: one chasing October, the other just trying to leave the Bronx with something to build on.

Mets 0, Yankees 2: Final Score & Odds Recap — Schlittler One-Hits Mets As Bombers Take Subway Series Finale