San Diego Padres at Milwaukee Brewers

By JR·2 min read
Padres(91-71)
Brewers(103-59)
Sunday 10/043:00 PM

TLDR: Game 1 came down to a Ty France fly ball that hit the American Family Field roof and dropped into Jackson Chourio's glove. Milwaukee leads the NLDS 1-0, and San Diego gets one more shot at 3:00 PM CT before the series heads west.

SUN OCT 4, 3:00 PMFS1
LWWWW
WWWWW

Milwaukee leads the NLDS 1-0 after a 3-2 Game 1 that ended with Ty France's would-be homer hitting the roof and being caught. Michael King, coming off 7 one-hit scoreless innings against the Cubs, faces rookie Logan Henderson in his postseason debut. Henderson has been excellent all year but walked 3 in his last start. San Diego's thin lineup is the biggest thing working against it, and Milwaukee is the home favorite.

San Diego Padres
  • King threw 7 one-hit scoreless innings vs Cubs
  • Wild Card sweep set the rotation up on full rest
  • Game 1 lost by a run on a roof-ball out
  • Andujar, Laureano, Rengifo all out of the lineup
  • Buehler away on paternity list
  • King gave up 5 earned runs to the Dodgers on 9/22
Milwaukee Brewers
  • Henderson: 2.47 ERA, 110 Ks in 98 1/3 innings
  • Contreras homer won Game 1; 5 straight wins
  • Rested and at home for a matinee
  • Henderson making his postseason debut
  • 3 walks in 5 innings in his last start
  • Barely any live at-bats in the past week

San Diego starts its best arm. In Game 1 of the Wild Card Series against the Cubs, Michael King (12-10, 3.21) allowed 1 hit over 7 scoreless innings, and the Padres are calling him their ace again. That start mattered more than his final regular-season turn against the Dodgers. Milwaukee answers with rookie Logan Henderson (11-3, 2.47), who makes his postseason debut against a team that beat him 2 months ago. He pitched well in that loss in San Diego: 6 1/3 innings, 3 earned runs, 7 strikeouts.

Michael King
Michael King
(12-10)·3.21 ERA
Sep 22 @ Dodgers
L
4.0IP
5ER
5K
2BB
81P
10/04 Lineup
Logan Henderson
Logan Henderson
(11-3)·2.47 ERA
Sep 23 @ Phillies
W
5.0IP
1ER
3K
3BB
87P
10/04 Lineup

Henderson is better than his rookie label. His 2.47 ERA over 18 starts came with 110 strikeouts in 98 1/3 innings. His last regular-season start was messier, though: 3 walks in 5 innings at Philadelphia. In a playoff game, a rookie who loses the zone early hands the game to the bullpen. San Diego's lineup is still thin. Miguel Andujar's wrist has kept him out, Ramon Laureano and Luis Rengifo are on the 60-day list, and Walker Buehler is on paternity leave. Milwaukee is the favorite at home, as a 103-win team should be.

Game 1 was as close as a 3-2 score suggests. William Contreras broke the tie with a homer in the 7th. In the 9th, France hit what looked like a go-ahead homer, and the roof turned it into an out. San Diego lost on a ball that would have been a homer anywhere without a roof over it. Milwaukee took the win anyway and kept its 5-game run going.

10/03L@Brewers2-3
09/30WvsCubs4-1
09/29WvsCubs8-0
09/27WvsDiamondbacks9-4
09/26WvsDiamondbacks10-7
10/03WvsPadres3-2
09/27WvsCardinals6-4
09/26WvsCardinals3-2
09/25WvsCardinals8-4
09/24W@Phillies5-1

The schedule helped San Diego. Sweeping the Cubs 2-0 in the Wild Card round meant the Padres didn't burn a 3rd starter, so King starts this game on full rest instead of someone further down the rotation. Milwaukee's run came in two parts. The Brewers swept the Cardinals 3-0 to close the regular season, sat during the Wild Card round and then took Game 1. They're rested and they're home. The risk is that they've barely faced live pitching in a week, and Game 1 showed that a little.

Milwaukee's injured list is mostly long-term pitching: Brandon Woodruff, Quinn Priester, Brian Fitzpatrick and Angel Zerpa, plus Grant Anderson on a rehab track. None of that changes who catches the ball today. San Diego's absences show up in the batting order. With Andujar, Laureano and Rengifo out, the Padres need King to keep the game close, because their bats aren't built to win a slugfest in October.

If Milwaukee wins, it goes to San Diego up 2-0 with 2 chances to finish the series. If San Diego wins, the series comes home tied and King's start becomes the turning point. Either way, it's a matinee between 2 good right-handers in a series that has already turned on the roof.

NLDS Game 2: San Diego Padres at Milwaukee Brewers — Padres Hand Michael King the Ball to Even the NLDS in Milwaukee | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush