Philadelphia Phillies at Atlanta Braves

Tue Sep 292:00 PM ETAtlanta, GA
By JR·3 min read
Philadelphia PhilliesPHI(88-74)
Atlanta BravesATL(94-68)
Tuesday2:00 PM ET

TLDR: The Braves and Phillies have both played all 162 and now meet in Atlanta in October, with bullpens already being lined up for it. Philadelphia gets there with an offense that stopped scoring for a week and without the man who led the National League in hitting.

TUE SEP 29, 2:00 PM
Spread
WIN
Total
(88-74)
WLLLL
(94-68)
LWLLW
1st pitch85°

Atlanta hosts Philadelphia after both clubs finished their 162, with the Braves 6 games better and lined up behind Sale, Holmes and Mahle. The Phillies were stuck on a 4-game skid in which they scored 3 runs before a 7-run finale against the Rays, and they are probably without NL batting leader Luis Arraez. Neither club has named a starter, and the game turns on whether Philadelphia's lineup can score against rested Atlanta pitching.

Phillies
  • Put up 7 runs in the Rays finale
  • Pitching limited Milwaukee to 4 and 5 runs
  • 3 runs total across a 4-game skid
  • Arraez's .310 bat likely missing
  • Bowlan day-to-day, Keller and Kilian out of pen
Braves
  • Sale's 2.16 ERA heads a rested top 3
  • Mahle has a 1.99 ERA since the deadline
  • Relievers rested on purpose on the final weekend
  • Dropped 2 of 3 in Miami
  • Rotation depth thin after Strider, Schwellenbach losses
  • Lopez and Elder out of the staff

Neither club has named a starter for Tuesday, September 29, and with a season on the line nobody should guess. Atlanta has the better set of options if the bullets get handed out in order. Chris Sale finished 14-9 with a 2.16 ERA, Grant Holmes was 10-6 with a 3.44, and deadline pickup Tyler Mahle went 4-1 with a 1.99 after coming over from San Francisco. Those three are the Braves' postseason rotation, whatever order Walt Weiss uses. First pitch is 2:00 PM ET.

The bigger lineup story is Philadelphia's. Luis Arraez sprained his left ankle against Milwaukee on September 24 and had to be helped off without putting weight on it. He was hitting .310 at the time, the best mark in the NL. Interim manager Don Mattingly called the diagnosis "not a great one." The Phillies kept him off the IL, but reporting has them possibly leaving him off the Wild Card roster altogether. The board has Atlanta as a clear favorite, and that feels about right for a team that finished 6 games better.

Philadelphia's final week is why this matters. In the 4 losses before the 7-3 win over Tampa Bay, the Phillies scored 3 runs total: 1, 1, 0 and 1. That covers 2 games against the Brewers and 2 against the Rays, all at home. The 7-run finale was the first time in a week the lineup looked like itself, and they're taking it on the road without their table-setter.

09/27WvsRays7-3
09/26LvsRays1-12
09/25LvsRays0-2
09/24LvsBrewers1-5
09/23LvsBrewers1-4
09/27L@Marlins3-5
09/26W@Marlins8-3
09/25L@Marlins0-3
09/24LvsReds6-7
09/23WvsReds3-2

Atlanta didn't exactly roar into October either. The Braves went 2-3 over their last 5 and dropped 2 of 3 in Miami. Some of that was on purpose. Weiss used the final weekend to give his pitchers appearances and rest rather than chase wins: Ray Kerr opened one game and Holmes piggybacked behind him. "We're trying to find a sweet spot between being rested and being ready to go," Weiss said. So the Braves' recent results tell you less than usual, and their fresh relievers tell you more.

The Braves have lost a lot of arms too. Spencer Strider and Spencer Schwellenbach are both done for the year, Bryce Elder and Reynaldo Lopez are on the 15-day IL, and Hurston Waldrep went on the 60-day. That's why depth past the top 3 starters is the soft spot. JR Ritchie, a converted reliever with a 4.79 ERA, is next in line. In a short series, though, Atlanta may never need to go that deep. Philadelphia's pitching list is thinner on paper: Brad Keller is out after elbow surgery, Caleb Kilian is on the 60-day, and Jonathan Bowlan is day-to-day with a groin strain.

Weather won't be a factor. It should be 85 degrees and clear at Truist Park with barely a 4 mph breeze. Everything else points to a low-scoring afternoon: two staffs lined up for the playoffs, rested bullpens, and a Phillies lineup that spent last week proving it can go 9 innings without scoring. If Philadelphia's bats from the Tampa Bay finale show up, this is a coin-flip rivalry game. If the bats from the 4 games before it show up, it's over by the 7th.

Live Odds