Pittsburgh Pirates at Milwaukee Brewers

Mon Aug 36:40 PM CT
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: The Brewers own the best record in the NL Central by a mile. The Pirates are barely a game under .500. None of that mattered Monday night.

FINAL · MON AUG 3, 11:40 PM
LWLLL
4
LWWLW
3
Final123456789RHE
PIT
003100000481
MIL
000012000361
Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Bubba Chandler is a legitimate Rookie of the Year candidate
  • Won last outing against Cincinnati before this game
  • Nothing to lose playing a division leader
  • 56-57 record, well off a playoff pace
  • Rotation just lost Mitch Keller for the season
  • Chandler's last start was rocky, 3 ER in 4 innings
Milwaukee Brewers
  • 69-42, among the best records in baseball
  • Added Dustin May and JoJo Romero at the deadline
  • Kyle Harrison back and ready to pitch
  • Dropped 2 of last 5 games entering this one
  • Sproat carries a 5.17 ERA and just took a loss
  • Several relievers (Romero, Kuhnel) still working back from injury

Brandon Sproat (3-6, 5.17) took the ball for Milwaukee against Pittsburgh rookie Bubba Chandler (3-8, 4.36), and on paper it read like a mismatch in the Brewers' favor. Chandler has been erratic all year, and Sproat was fresh off a loss to the Giants. But rotations don't always follow the standings, and Monday was a reminder of that.

Bubba Chandler
Bubba Chandler
(6-8)·4.23 ERA
Jul 28 vs Diamondbacks
ND
4.0IP
3ER
3K
1BB
91P
08/03 Lineup
Brandon Sproat
Brandon Sproat
(3-7)·5.27 ERA
Jul 27 @ Giants
L
6.0IP
3ER
5K
3BB
97P
08/03 Lineup

The bigger pitching story in Pittsburgh actually broke hours before first pitch: the Pirates placed Mitch Keller on the 60-day injured list with a right arm teres major injury, officially ending his season and leaving the rotation thinner behind Chandler and Paul Skenes. Milwaukee, meanwhile, went the opposite direction at the deadline, adding rotation and bullpen pieces in Dustin May and JoJo Romero from the Cardinals in a rare in-division trade after missing out on Tarik Skubal.

None of that swung the price much. Milwaukee opened as a heavy favorite on the moneyline and run line, with sharp money piling onto the Brewers side pregame -- 27 tracked bets worth just over $2,100, most of it stacked on Milwaukee. The board liked the home team. The board was wrong.

Pittsburgh did its damage early and often, plating 3 in the 3rd and adding another in the 4th to build a 4-0 cushion before Milwaukee's bats woke up. The Brewers answered with a run in the 5th and 2 more in the 6th to cut it to 4-3, but they couldn't finish the rally -- 3 scoreless innings to close it out let the Pirates escape with the win despite being outhit only 8-6.

08/02L@Reds2-10
08/01W@Reds4-1
07/31L@Reds7-8
07/30L@Reds2-3
07/29LvsDiamondbacks0-3
08/02L@Angels0-3
08/02W@Angels3-1
08/01W@Angels6-2
07/29L@Giants3-16
07/29W@Giants8-2

It's the kind of result that looks better on Pittsburgh's ledger than its overall season does. The Pirates have been streaky all year, and Chandler -- still very much a Rookie of the Year candidate despite the walk issues that have plagued him -- got enough length and enough swings-and-misses to hand a lead to the bullpen. Sproat's shaky command continues to be the swing factor for Milwaukee's rotation depth, and it bit them again.

For a Brewers team that just spent its deadline capital trying to armor up for October, a night like this is a shrug-it-off loss in a 162-game season -- but it's also a reminder that a 69-42 record doesn't guarantee anything on a given Monday against a team with nothing to lose.

Pirates 4, Brewers 3: Final Score & Odds Recap — Pirates Shock First-Place Brewers 4-3 in Milwaukee