Pittsburgh Pirates at Chicago White Sox

Tue Sep 86:40 PM CT
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: The White Sox came in chasing a first-round bye. The Pirates spent the first inning making that math a lot harder.

FINAL · TUE SEP 8, 11:40 PM
WLWWL
9
3
Final123456789RHE
PIT
5200200009180
CWS
000011100360
Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Won their last game, taken 2 of 3 from Angels
  • Chandler has had scoreless outings this season
  • Under 2% playoff odds entering September, per MLB.com
  • Bullpen down Yates; Keller and Rodriguez out long-term
Chicago White Sox
  • Leading AL Central, rookies Murakami and Peters producing
  • Burke scoreless in his last start, strong recent form
  • Lost 2 of last 3 to Houston before this set
  • Missing both catchers and left fielder Pham

On paper this one looked tight: Bubba Chandler (6-9, 4.25 ERA) against Sean Burke (8-6, 3.46 ERA), the Pirates' promising righty against the arm that's carried Chicago's rotation all year. Burke was coming off a gem, 5.2 scoreless innings at Houston with 6 strikeouts against a single hit. Chandler's last time out was shakier, 5 innings and 3 earned runs against San Francisco with as many walks as strikeouts allowed. First pitch went off at 6:40 PM CT at Rate Field, and none of that form held up the way it read on paper.

Bubba Chandler
Bubba Chandler
(8-9)·4.34 ERA
Sep 2 vs Giants
ND
5.0IP
3ER
4K
3BB
88P
09/08 Lineup
Sean Burke
Sean Burke
(10-7)·3.40 ERA
Sep 1 @ Astros
W
5.2IP
0ER
6K
4BB
104P
09/08 Lineup

Chicago walked into Tuesday missing two regulars already, catcher Joey Bart and left fielder Tommy Pham, both battling their own injuries, and the pitching staff behind Burke has been thin for weeks — Anthony Kay hasn't finished five innings in his recent turns, and Luis Castillo has been rough since Chicago acquired him. Burke has quietly gone five straight starts without a quality start himself, per the Chicago Sun-Times, even while owning the rotation's best number. None of that was reason for panic walking in. It became the story of the night.

Pittsburgh didn't wait around. The first five balls the Pirates put in play against Burke left the bat at 99.5 mph or harder, and the first 7 hitters he faced all reached base, according to the Sun-Times. By the time Burke walked the bases loaded and was pulled early in the second inning, the deficit was already enormous, and Chandler had all the cushion he needed to work with.

Burke finished with a career-high 7 runs allowed on 8 hits in just 1.1 innings, a stunning reversal from the scoreless outing he'd turned in five days earlier. Chicago's bullpen mopped up from there, and while the offense clawed back a run in each of the 5th, 6th and 7th innings to make it respectable, the hole from that first inning was always going to be too deep to climb out of against a Pirates lineup that had 18 hits on the night.

09/06WvsAngels1-0
09/05LvsAngels1-6
09/04WvsAngels1-0
09/03WvsGiants5-2
09/02LvsGiants4-5
09/06WvsTwins10-1
09/05LvsTwins4-6
09/04WvsTwins4-1
09/03L@Astros2-6
09/02L@Astros0-2

The Polymarket chat room noticed the shift fast — "Pirates gonna fumble this" got 19 reactions in the early innings, and even as the lead held, someone still holding the White Sox cracked "pirates known for blowing 9-0 leads" for another 15. Neither one aged well. Pittsburgh's bullpen, which has been one of the better units in the sport since the trade deadline, needed only to hold a laugher, and did.

Both clubs are still fighting for something. The White Sox, two years removed from a 41-121 season, are trying to lock up their first playoff trip since 2021 and would rather not be searching for rotation answers with 2.5 weeks left, per the Sun-Times. Manager Will Venable floated leaning harder on bullpen games behind Burke if the rest of the rotation doesn't settle down. Pittsburgh, at 71-73, needs a real hot streak the rest of the way to make any playoff noise at all — Tuesday was exactly the kind of game that keeps that thin hope alive.

Pirates 9, White Sox 3: Final Score & Odds Recap — Pirates Blitz Burke Early, Cruise Past White Sox 9-3