Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees

By JR·2 min read
Boston Red SoxBOS(87-75)
New York YankeesNYY(93-68)
Wednesday 09/308:00 PM

TLDR: Boston got shut out 9-0 in Game 1 at Yankee Stadium, and in a best-of-3 that means one more loss ends the season. Now the Red Sox have to win in the Bronx with a lineup that just went quiet and a leadoff man whose hand is acting up again.

THU OCT 1, 8:00 PM
(87-75)
LLWWL
(93-68)
WWLWW

The Yankees lead the best-of-3 Wild Card Series 1-0 after a 9-0 Game 1 win, so Boston faces elimination in the Bronx with Sonny Gray against Max Fried. The pitching matchup is close to even. The game likely turns on whether Boston's banged-up lineup, which may be missing Roman Anthony after his hand flared up again, can do anything against Fried, while New York keeps producing without Aaron Judge.

Boston Red Sox
  • Gray: 18-5, 2.72, 6 scoreless innings last start
  • Gray rested after a 77-pitch outing
  • Won 1- and 2-run games against the Cubs
  • Anthony's hand flared up again, Game 2 status unclear
  • 8 runs in the last 5, shut out twice
  • Bullpen without Slaten and Guerrero
New York Yankees
  • Scored 9 in Game 1 without Judge
  • Rice hot: 4-for-5, 2 HR, 6 RBI
  • 4-1 in the last 5, won 2 straight
  • Judge (calf) not on the Wild Card roster
  • Fried gave up 4 earned runs last start
  • Fried's 5-5 record reflects thin run support

The Red Sox hand it to Sonny Gray, and on paper he is the right man for it. He's 18-5 with a 2.72 ERA, he's a former Yankee, and his last start was 6 scoreless innings against Cleveland on just 77 pitches, so he comes in rested. Max Fried is New York's answer: a 3-time All-Star with a 2.80 ERA, though his 5-5 record says the Yankees haven't scored much for him. His last time out was the shakiest of the 2, with 4 earned runs over 6.2 innings against Tampa Bay. First pitch is 8:00 PM ET.

Sonny Gray
Sonny Gray
(18-5)·2.72 ERA
Sep 23 vs Guardians
W
6.0IP
0ER
3K
1BB
77P
09/30 Lineup
Max Fried
Max Fried
(5-5)·2.80 ERA
Sep 22 vs Rays
L
6.2IP
4ER
4K
2BB
97P
09/30 Lineup

The Boston lineup is the bigger worry. Roman Anthony left Game 1 after a few check swings against Cam Schlittler set off the same right hand that cost him close to 4 months this year, following a partially torn tendon in his ring finger in May. Boston hadn't said whether he plays Game 2. Behind him the depth is gone too: Mickey Gasper needs biceps surgery, Romy Gonzalez was optioned to Worcester, and Masataka Yoshida and Triston Casas have been out a long time. The Yankees are playing short as well, with Aaron Judge (calf) left off the Wild Card roster, and they still put 9 on the board without him.

Game 1 was a pair of Massachusetts kids beating the home-state team. Schlittler gave up 2 singles and 1 walk over 6⅓ innings, and Ben Rice went 4-for-5 with 2 homers and 6 RBI, the last 4 on an 8th-inning grand slam that turned a pitchers' duel against Payton Tolle into a rout. With a 64-degree cloudy night and barely any wind in the forecast, nothing about the weather should help either offense.

09/29L@Yankees0-9
09/27LvsCubs2-6
09/25WvsCubs2-0
09/25WvsCubs4-3
09/24LvsGuardians0-1
09/29WvsRed Sox9-0
09/25WvsOrioles6-3
09/25LvsOrioles2-10
09/24WvsRays6-4
09/23WvsRays9-2

Boston's recent form is a real warning sign. In their last 5 they scored 0, 4, 2, 2 and 0, which is 8 runs total with 2 shutouts, and that includes a 1-0 loss to Cleveland in which the pitching did its job. They took 2 of 3 from the Cubs by scraping out 1- and 2-run wins. That's how Boston has to win tonight too: Gray goes deep, the bullpen holds a small lead, and somebody gets 1 big hit. The Yankees have won 4 of their last 5 and 2 straight, and Rice's night showed this lineup can still do damage with Judge on the bench.

Boston's injury list is long, and it has hit the pitching staff as well as the lineup. Justin Slaten went to the 60-day IL and Tyron Guerrero is out with a shoulder strain, which thins out the relievers who would protect a late lead for Gray. New York's list is shorter, but Judge's name at the top of it changes how pitchers can attack their order. It's Yankees-Red Sox in October with Boston's season on the line, so neither side will hold anything back.

Live Odds

Betting
AL Wild Card Game 2: Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees — Red Sox Hand Sonny Gray The Ball With The Season On The Line | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush