Detroit Tigers at Cleveland Guardians Game 1

Fri Sep 42:10 PM ET
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Cleveland trailed by 3 for most of an afternoon delayed by rain, then scratched across the winning run in the ninth to steal the opener of a split doubleheader from Detroit.

FINAL · FRI SEP 4, 6:10 PM
LWLLL
3
4
Final12345678910RHE
DET
0020100000390
CLE
0000010201460
Detroit Tigers
  • Montero coming off a clean, efficient look at LA
  • Jumped to a 3-0 lead early on the road
  • Carpenter and Vierling both still on the 10-day IL
  • Lost 4 of last 5 including this one
Cleveland Guardians
  • DeLauter hitting .363 with a .978 OPS since August 1
  • Won 3 of last 5 with the late-game formula on display
  • Logan Allen making first start since July 18
  • Holderman landed on 15-day IL same day, pen thinned

Keider Montero came in off a clean look at the Dodgers, and the Guardians countered with Logan Allen, freshly recalled and making his first big-league start since July 18. That gap alone made this an unpredictable arm to build a game plan around, and it showed early.

Keider Montero
Keider Montero
(9-9)·3.58 ERA
Aug 29 vs Dodgers
ND
5.1IP
1ER
3K
1BB
73P
09/04 Lineup
Logan Allen
Logan Allen
(0-0)·5.94 ERA
Jul 18 vs Pirates
ND
3.1IP
2ER
3K
3BB
81P
09/04 Lineup

Detroit's lineup is missing real thump with Kerry Carpenter and Matt Vierling both still on the 10-day IL, but the group that took the field did enough damage against Allen early to make the absences look irrelevant, at least for a few innings. Cleveland, meanwhile, got its best everyday bat back in the fold: Chase DeLauter, who's been raking basically since the calendar flipped to August.

None of that stopped the total from creeping up before first pitch, with the market leaning toward more scoring as game time got closer. That numbers-move context matters less once the linescore actually fills in, and this one filled in unevenly.

Detroit jumped to a 2-0 lead in the third and made it 3-0 in the fifth, and for a long stretch this looked like exactly the laugher a rebuilding-year Tigers club needed. Cleveland clawed a run back in the sixth, tied it with a two-run eighth, and then walked it off with a single run in the ninth for a 4-3 win — the kind of finish that erases a pitching line nobody will remember by October.

09/04L@Guardians6-7
09/02W@Twins11-6
09/01L@Twins2-15
08/31L@Twins1-11
08/30LvsDodgers1-6
09/04WvsTigers7-6
09/03LvsBlue Jays3-6
09/02LvsBlue Jays0-11
09/01WvsBlue Jays6-1
08/30WvsRoyals11-1

The result fits a pattern for both sides. Detroit's last five have been ugly outside of one blowout win over Minnesota, and this loss extends that skid. Cleveland, by contrast, keeps finding ways to win the game in front of it rather than the one on paper — DeLauter's bat is doing real work there, and it papered over another shaky start from a rotation piece still finding his legs.

The doubleheader format did some damage of its own. Colin Holderman landed on the 15-day IL the same day with wrist inflammation, thinning a Cleveland bullpen that just had to cover extra innings across two games, and both Hao-Yu Lee and Angel Martinez were banged up and pulled from the nightcap. None of that touched this particular final score, but it's the kind of fallout that follows a club into the rest of this four-game set.

Tigers 3, Guardians 4: Final Score & Odds Recap — Guardians Walk It Off To Open Tigers Doubleheader