Chicago White Sox at St. Louis Cardinals

Sat Sep 126:15 PM CTSt. Louis, MO
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: David Sandlin was nearly untouchable for five-plus innings, and it still wasn't enough — a sixth-inning miscue turned into a 3-1 Cardinals win that trimmed Chicago's AL Central cushion down to a half-game over Cleveland.

FINAL · SAT SEP 12, 11:15 PM
1
3
Final123456789RHE
CWS
010000000141
STL
00000300—340
62°

St. Louis beat Chicago 3-1, with all 3 runs unearned after a Colson Montgomery error in the sixth inning turned a David Sandlin gem into a loss. The result trimmed the White Sox's AL Central lead over Cleveland to a half-game heading into their next series.

Chicago White Sox
  • Sandlin carried a perfect game into the sixth inning
  • Struck out 5 over 5.2 scoreless, unearned-run innings
  • Montgomery's error on a hard grounder opened the sixth
  • Finished 0-for-7 with runners in scoring position
  • Montgomery hitless in 6 of his last 7 games
St. Louis Cardinals
  • Burleson's double cashed all 3 runs off the error
  • Winn and Church set up the rally with back-to-back singles
  • Scored zero earned runs on the night
  • Offense limited to 4 hits as a team

The preview framed this one around Luis Castillo and Kyle Leahy, but it was David Sandlin who actually took the ball for Chicago, and he was brilliant — retiring the first 16 batters he faced and carrying a perfect-game bid into the sixth inning before it unraveled. He finished with 5.2 innings, 2 hits and 5 strikeouts, all 3 runs he allowed unearned, and afterward called it about as simple as a pitcher can: he should have gotten through the sixth clean and given his team a better shot, per the Chicago Sun-Times.

Sean Newcomb
Sean Newcomb
(2-5)·3.17 ERA
Aug 23 vs Mets
ND
2.0IP
0ER
3K
0BB
38P
09/12 Lineup
Kyle Leahy
Kyle Leahy
(10-5)·3.66 ERA
Sep 6 @ Rockies
ND
2.2IP
5ER
6K
0BB
55P
09/12 Lineup

Masyn Winn, back in the lineup after the thumb injury that had him sidelined, singled to open the sixth alongside Nathan Church, and Ivan Herrera followed with a 103.6 mph grounder that shortstop Colson Montgomery couldn't field cleanly, loading the bases. Manager Will Venable went to lefty Chris Murphy to face Alec Burleson, and Burleson turned it into a bases-clearing double down the right-field line that put St. Louis ahead for good, per the Sun-Times.

Chicago had its own chance to answer — Sam Antonacci opened the sixth with a leadoff triple that went to waste after he got caught in a rundown — and the offense finished the night 0-for-7 with runners in scoring position, its only run a second-inning sacrifice fly from Chase Meidroth. The Polymarket chat drew a season-high crowd for the series, and the room's busiest stretch of the night landed right around Burleson's double breaking the game open.

Montgomery's error was the costliest of the night, but it also fit a broader pattern — he's gone hitless in 6 of his last 7 games and has struck out at roughly a 40% clip since the All-Star break, a slump deep enough that it's put him on pace to challenge MLB's single-season strikeout record even with 26 home runs still on the year, per South Side Sox. He was blunt about the play itself afterward: you just have to make it.

09/13L@Cardinals1-3
09/12W@Cardinals6-5
09/11L@Cardinals3-7
09/10LvsPirates0-2
09/09LvsPirates2-4
09/13WvsWhite Sox3-1
09/12LvsWhite Sox5-6
09/11WvsWhite Sox7-3
09/09L@Giants6-7
09/08L@Giants1-2

The loss dropped Chicago to a half-game lead over Cleveland in a division race the White Sox have owned since late June, and the two clubs now head into a head-to-head series with the gap that tight. In the Polymarket room, one poster holding Chicago tried to talk up Munetaka Murakami before the Cardinals' bats did the deciding; another holding St. Louis was blunter once Burleson connected: "cash cash cash."

White Sox 1, Cardinals 3: Final Score & Odds Recap — One Shortstop Error Turns Into Three Runs, Sinks White Sox