Chicago White Sox at Cleveland Guardians

Mon Oct 55:00 PM ETTBS,truTVCleveland, OH
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Chicago came into Cleveland and shut out the AL Central's postseason host in Game 1, and now the Guardians get one more home game before this series goes anywhere else. Monday's Game 2 is the closest thing to a must-answer a 1-0 deficit can be.

MON OCT 5, 5:00 PMTBStruTV
1st pitch59°15 mph

The White Sox lead the ALDS 1-0 after a 3-0 Game 1 shutout behind Munetaka Murakami's 2-run homer and 4 scoreless innings from Grant Taylor. Cleveland starts Gavin Williams, its strikeout ace, in Game 2. He's coming off a regular-season finale where he walked 4 in 3.1 innings. Chicago is expected to cover the bulk innings with Sean Burke in some form, and Cleveland's lineup has to start cashing its chances against a bullpen that has been throwing a lot of innings.

Chicago White Sox
  • Bullpen threw a 3-hit shutout in Game 1
  • Murakami's power already decided 1 game in this series
  • Won 4 straight, including a sweep at Houston
  • No announced starter, likely another opener game
  • Taylor threw 4 innings in Game 1
  • Castillo out with shoulder impingement
Cleveland Guardians
  • Williams struck out 248 with 11 double-digit-K starts
  • Scored 23 runs in 2 games at Kansas City late in the season
  • Shut out at home and 0-for-2 with the bases loaded
  • Williams walked 4 in 3.1 innings his last time out
  • Holderman and Walters gone from the bullpen

Cleveland hands the ball to Gavin Williams, and that's exactly who Stephen Vogt wanted here. Williams (14-8, 3.76) made 32 starts, struck out 248 in 184.1 innings and had 11 starts with double-digit strikeouts. Chicago hasn't named its starter for Monday's 5:00 PM ET first pitch. Will Venable has leaned on a modified-opener approach, and MLB.com reports that Sean Burke will do the bulk work whether he starts or comes in during the 2nd or 3rd. Treat that as a projection until the White Sox make it official.

Chicago White Sox
TBD
—
TBD
ND
—IP
—ER
—K
—BB
—P
10/05 Lineup
Gavin Williams
Gavin Williams
(14-8)·3.76 ERA
Sep 25 @ Royals
ND
3.1IP
4ER
4K
4BB
74P
10/05 Lineup

The question with Williams is his last start of the regular season. He went 3.1 innings at Kansas City and allowed 4 earned runs on 5 hits with 4 walks, needing 74 pitches to get 10 outs. In that game he wasn't beating himself on contact. He was missing the zone. That matters against a White Sox lineup that just made Cleveland pay for a single swing: Munetaka Murakami's 440-foot, 2-run homer in the 4th was all the scoring Game 1 needed. Chicago is also playing without Luis Castillo, who went on the 15-day IL in late September with right shoulder impingement. That's a big reason the Sox are piecing games together the way they are.

The Chicago bullpen is the real reason the Sox lead the series. 5 pitchers combined on a 3-hitter in Game 1, and Grant Taylor got the last 12 outs without allowing a run. Cleveland came off its bye flat. It loaded the bases in back-to-back innings and went 0-for-2 in those spots. The open question for Monday is how much of that bullpen is still fresh after Taylor's 4-inning outing, especially if Chicago goes with an opener again.

Both clubs got here hot. Chicago is 4-1 in its last 5 and had won 4 straight as of Game 1. That run included a 2-0 sweep in Houston and a split of its last 2 against Colorado before the ALDS. Cleveland closed the regular season by taking 2 of 3 from Kansas City, which included 12-9 and 11-5 wins. It then lost the finale 3-2 and was shut out in Game 1. The Guardians lineup that put up 23 runs across 2 games in Kansas City scored 0 at home on Saturday.

10/03W@Guardians3-0
09/30W@Astros7-3
09/29W@Astros6-3
09/27WvsRockies4-2
09/26LvsRockies6-9
10/03LvsWhite Sox0-3
09/27L@Royals2-3
09/26W@Royals11-5
09/25W@Royals12-9
09/24W@Red Sox1-0

Cleveland is short a few pieces too. Rhys Hoskins (back) is still on the 10-day IL working through a swing progression. Colin Holderman is headed for season-ending wrist surgery, and Andrew Walters had UCL repair, which takes 2 relievers out of the bullpen. Chicago's list is longer. Joey Bart's hand fracture took a catcher off the roster, and relievers Prelander Berroa, Jordan Leasure and Mike Vasil are all on the 60-day.

The forecast is clear and 59 degrees with 15 mph of wind. That's crisp October baseball at Progressive Field. Williams is exactly the kind of arm that can even a series by himself, and Cleveland needs him to. If Chicago's patchwork pitching holds the Guardians down again, the series heads to the South Side with the White Sox up 2-0.

ALDS Game 2: Chicago White Sox at Cleveland Guardians — White Sox Take a 1-0 ALDS Lead Into Monday at Progressive Field | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush