Toronto Maple Leafs at New York Islanders

Mon Nov 237:30 PM ETESPN+Elmont, NY
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Toronto has gone 8 games without a win, and on Monday, November 23, it visits an Islanders team that hasn't lost in regulation in 7. Somebody's streak gives at UBS Arena, and it's a lot easier to guess which one.

TUE 11/24, 7:30 PMESPN+

Toronto visits Elmont at 8-13-3 and without a win in 8 straight, including a 4-3 shootout loss to Los Angeles in which it blew a 3-0 lead. The Islanders have earned a point in 7 straight, most recently with a 3-2 comeback win in Detroit, and Matthew Schaefer has 8 points in his last 4 games. The question is whether Toronto's top players can protect a lead for once against a home team that has kept coming back.

Toronto Maple Leafs
  • Matthews still scoring early, franchise-record opening goals
  • Stolarz made 25 saves in the Kings loss
  • Top 6 built a 3-0 lead vs L.A.
  • 0-7-1 in last 8 games
  • Gave up 3 goals in under 12 minutes vs Kings
  • Coaching uncertainty hanging over Hiller
New York Islanders
  • 7-game point streak
  • Schaefer has 8 points in last 4
  • Came back from 1-0 down in Detroit
  • Fell behind early in Detroit again
  • Detroit win came against a short-handed Wings team

The Islanders have mostly been winning on time spent in the other team's end. In Saturday's 3-2 win in Detroit they fell behind 1-0 on Emmitt Finnie's 1st-period goal and then didn't panic. Ondrej Palat scored twice, Matthew Schaefer set up Simon Holmstrom's go-ahead goal early in the 3rd, and a short-handed Red Wings team, still without Dylan Larkin, finished with just 20 shots. That result stretched New York's point streak to 7 games.

Schaefer is the reason this one is worth watching. A few days before Detroit, he scored his first career hat trick in a 5-1 win over Columbus at UBS Arena. He's only the 3rd defenseman in Islanders history to do it and the first since Denis Potvin in 1982. He followed it with 2 assists against the Wings, which gave him 8 points in his last 4 games. He also has 6 career multigoal games, the most ever by a teenage defenseman. When the Islanders push the pace, he's usually the one carrying the puck.

Toronto is in a different place entirely. The Maple Leafs are 8-13-3 and 0-7-1 in their past 8. The latest was a 4-3 shootout loss to the Kings at Scotiabank Arena, and it was a bad one. Auston Matthews, John Tavares and Dakota Joshua had Toronto up 3-0 early in the 2nd. Los Angeles then scored 3 times in under 12 minutes and Adrian Kempe ended it in the shootout. There's open talk about Jim Hiller's job security, and the team cancelled a practice in the middle of the skid.

11/22LvsBlue Jackets3-4
11/20LvsKings3-4
11/18L@Blackhawks3-6
11/15LvsOilers0-1
11/13LvsWild2-5
11/22W@Red Wings3-2
11/20L@Jets3-4
11/18WvsBlue Jackets5-1
11/15W@Ducks6-2
11/13W@Kings5-2

Toronto can still score, so this isn't a talent problem. Matthews had a goal and an assist against L.A., and his opener was the 68th game-opening goal of his career, which passed Mats Sundin for the franchise record. William Nylander picked up an assist to end a 5-game pointless run. The problem is everything after the goal. Hiller said it plainly: "It's just been too many times where we've scored and the next shift they've scored." Against a team that turned a 1-0 deficit in Detroit into a win, a Leafs lead early is only a starting point.

In net, Anthony Stolarz made 25 saves against the Kings and wasn't the reason Toronto lost. His team in front of him has been. For the Islanders, the job is the same one that's worked for 7 straight games: stay patient, let Schaefer and the forwards wear down the defense, and wait for the Leafs to leave a lane open. Puck drop is 7:30 PM ET. Toronto needs a full 60 minutes, which it hasn't played in weeks.

Neither team plays again before Monday, so both get some rest and a couple of practice days. For Toronto, those days come with an 8-game skid and plenty of questions about the coach. The Islanders are fresh off a road win and have an easy plan to stick with.

Free Picks
Maple Leafs vs. Islanders: Polymarket Odds & Prediction (Nov. 23) — Reeling Maple Leafs Walk Into UBS Arena Against Surging Islanders