Pittsburgh Penguins at Columbus Blue Jackets

Fri Oct 97:00 PM ETESPN+Columbus, OH
By JR·2 min read

TLDR: Pittsburgh's first week has gone 7-0 one night and 6-5 the next. The Penguins get the Capitals before they reach Nationwide Arena for an early Metropolitan Division game against the Blue Jackets on Friday, October 9.

FRI OCT 9, 7:00 PMESPN+

Pittsburgh reaches Columbus on Friday, October 9, after a run-and-gun opening week of 15 goals for and 8 against, and with a stop in Washington still to come first. The Penguins are thin on the right wing with Rust and Brazeau on injured reserve and have an unproven Murashov-Silovs pairing in net. Columbus leans on the Fantilli-Marchenko-Nichushkin top line and Jet Greaves, with Merzlikins out after surgery. No prices are posted yet.

Pittsburgh Penguins
  • 15 goals in first 3 games, including a 7-0 rout
  • Crosby, Malkin, Karlsson, Letang all on the roster
  • Rust and Brazeau both on IR, right side thin
  • 8 goals allowed in last 2 games
  • Murashov-Silovs tandem unproven as a No. 1
Columbus Blue Jackets
  • Fantilli-Marchenko-Nichushkin projected as a big top line
  • Greaves projected starter after strong 2025-26
  • Merzlikins out after surgery, Copley is the backup
  • Power play and finishing were weak spots last season

Through 3 games the Penguins have been all over the place, which beats being boring. They opened with a 7-0 thrashing in Philadelphia, outlasted Montreal 6-5 at home, then dropped a 3-2 decision to Winnipeg. That's 15 goals for and 8 against. The offense showed up early, but the back end has leaked lately. Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Erik Karlsson and Kris Letang are all still on the opening-night roster, so the core is the same one fans have watched for years. Around them it's a lot of new and young names: Egor Chinakhov, Rutger McGroarty, Ville Koivunen, Elmer Soderblom.

Pittsburgh still has a game to play first. The Penguins are at Washington on Wednesday, October 7, the Capitals' home opener and the 101st career meeting between Crosby and Alex Ovechkin. That game settles a lot for this one: who's in net, how the lineup holds up, and whether this week's form still looks the same by Friday. The record you see on the card today is the record as of Tuesday, not the one Pittsburgh brings into Columbus.

The Penguins also have a real hole on the right side. They opened the season with 5 players on injured reserve: Bryan Rust, Justin Brazeau, Ryan Graves, Ben Kindel and Blake Lizotte. Losing Rust and Brazeau takes 2 right wingers out of the lineup at once, so a young forward group gets asked to do more. In goal, the opening roster carried Sergei Murashov and Arturs Silovs. Neither one is a proven No. 1 who'll take 60 starts, and the 8 goals allowed across the last 2 games are on that duo as much as on the defense.

10/05LvsJets2-3
10/03WvsCanadiens6-5
09/30W@Flyers7-0
10/03LvsMammoth1-4
10/01WvsSabres6-3

Columbus opened its 26th season on October 1 against Buffalo. It's also the first year of the NHL's new 84-game schedule. The Blue Jackets' attack is built around Adam Fantilli, with Kirill Marchenko and Valeri Nichushkin projected on his wings on the top line. That's a big, fast line that can tilt the ice against any second pair Pittsburgh rolls out. Columbus finished 19th in scoring last season with the 22nd-ranked power play, so turning chances into goals is the question this group is still answering.

In net, Jet Greaves is the projected starter after a strong 2025-26. The depth behind him is thinner than planned: Elvis Merzlikins had offseason surgery with no timeline to return, which leaves Phoenix Copley as the backup. If Greaves holds up, Columbus has a clean answer in goal. If he doesn't, or if the schedule forces a Copley start, a Penguins team that already has a 7-goal night and a 6-goal night this season will be happy to see it.

The matchup to watch is the Fantilli line against a Pittsburgh defense that has given up goals in bunches lately, while Crosby and Malkin try to keep feeding a forward group that's missing its 2 right wingers. Puck drop is 7:00 PM ET at Nationwide Arena. The board has no prices up yet, and how Wednesday goes in Washington will shape this one more than anything that has happened so far.

Pittsburgh Penguins at Columbus Blue Jackets — Penguins Visit Columbus After a Wild, Leaky Opening Week | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush