Dallas Stars at Pittsburgh Penguins

Sat Oct 107:00 PM ETESPN+Pittsburgh, PA
By JR·2 min read
Stars(2-2-0)
Penguins(2-2-0)
Saturday 10/107:00 PM

TLDR: Jake Oettinger has pitched back-to-back shutouts, and the Pittsburgh Penguins will score for anybody but themselves. Something has to give at PPG Paints Arena on Saturday, October 10.

SAT 10/10, 7:00 PMESPN+
WWLL

Dallas comes into Pittsburgh with Jake Oettinger on 2 straight shutouts, but they came against a Sharks team missing its best player and a Sabres team that has struggled to score. Pittsburgh scores plenty and has been leaky on defense, and it plays in Columbus the night before. That back-to-back, plus whether Kuzmenko returns for the home game, will shape the matchup more than either team's 2-2-0 record.

Dallas Stars
  • Oettinger has back-to-back shutouts
  • 3-goal 2nd period put Buffalo away
  • Day of rest after Buffalo, opponent on a back-to-back
  • Shutouts came vs weak, short-handed offenses
  • Duchene on LTIR, Kiviranta out
  • 1 goal total in the first 2 games
Pittsburgh Penguins
  • Has scored at least 2 in every game
  • Rust back and scored in his return
  • Second night of a back-to-back after Columbus
  • 13 goals allowed in 4 games
  • Graves out indefinitely on the blue line

The Dallas Stars' season opened badly: they were blanked 4-0 at home by St. Louis, then lost 2-1 in Nashville. As of Thursday it looks completely different. Oettinger stopped everything in a 5-0 win over San Jose and then did it again in Buffalo, a 4-0 game that was decided by a 3-goal 2nd period. Jason Robertson, Sam Steel and Roope Hintz all scored in Buffalo. Two straight clean sheets will get a goalie noticed in any month.

Pittsburgh is the reverse. The Penguins can score. They put 7 on Philadelphia and 6 on Montreal. They just can't keep the puck out of their own net, and they've lost 2 straight as of Thursday, including a 5-3 loss in Washington where the Capitals led 4-3 after 2 and Ryan Leonard put it away in the 3rd. Bryan Rust returned from an upper-body injury in that game and scored right away. That gives Dan Muse back a winger he'd gone 3 games without. Andrei Kuzmenko is the open question. The NHL gave him non-roster status after his father's death, and Muse said he wouldn't play on this road trip. Whether he's back for the home game Saturday hasn't been settled.

The big variable is that Pittsburgh plays first. The Penguins are in Columbus on Friday, then come home to face Dallas the next night. Dallas will have had a day off after Buffalo. Whatever happens against the Blue Jackets changes how this one looks: a third straight loss or a win to stop the slide, plus a goalie decision on the second night of a back-to-back and legs that just played 60 minutes. None of that is known yet, so this preview stays with what will still be true at puck drop.

10/08W@Sabres4-0
10/06WvsSharks5-0
10/04L@Predators1-2
10/03LvsBlues0-4
10/07L@Capitals3-5
10/05LvsJets2-3
10/03WvsCanadiens6-5
09/30W@Flyers7-0

Look at who Dallas shut out before you buy the shutout run completely. San Jose played without Macklin Celebrini, and Buffalo had been winning on late comebacks before the Stars built a lead the Sabres couldn't come back from. The Stars only had 1 goal combined in the first 2 games of the year. Pittsburgh has scored in every game, so it's the first real test of whether Oettinger's run is a trend or just a soft schedule.

Dallas is also playing short-handed. Matt Duchene is on long-term injured reserve with a lower-body injury, retroactive to Sept. 29, and Joel Kiviranta is out, so the middle-six depth is getting stretched. Pittsburgh is without defenseman Ryan Graves indefinitely and without winger Justin Brazeau, both with lower-body injuries. Losing Graves matters more for a team that has given up 13 goals in 4 games.

Puck drops at 7:00 PM ET. Both teams are 2-2-0, and on paper it's the best defensive team on the early schedule against the most fun-to-watch, least reliable offense. If the Penguins come home tired and have to chase, it'll get away from them by the 2nd period. If Rust gets the power play going and Pittsburgh scores early on Oettinger, his run ends in a building that has seen plenty of goals already.

Dallas Stars at Pittsburgh Penguins — Oettinger's Shutout Run Heads to Pittsburgh for Saturday Night | Polymarket Odds · Barstool Bush